RetroFed Forums
Your home away from modern life.
Movie details
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
shartgargle lemmy.zip shartgargle@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-08-09
#202 · Quote Reply

This makes me want to see a fully automatic revolver. If you're going to be absurd, lean into it.

Mini guns?

5
shartgargle lemmy.zip shartgargle@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-08-09
#203 · Quote Reply

What? Revolvers are really common. They're incredibly reliable, in a way that a semi auto mag fed pistol isn't. A revolver rotates the cylinder and the hammer falls on each individual round. If the ammo is bad (incredibly rare but it happens) then nothing happens, but just pull the trigger again and you're not jammed or anything. A mag-fed semi auto, while higher capacity, has WAY more complica...

You're buying the wrong pistols then. You can throw a Glock in mid then run 800 rounds through it without cleaning, without jamming. And reloading a pistol is much easier than reloading a revolver. They also don't kick nearly as much as a revolver, making them far more accurate.

0
shartgargle lemmy.zip shartgargle@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-08-09
#204 · Quote Reply

They still make revolvers today. They’re supposedly more reliable and easier to maintain.

That was true until about the late 90's. There are quite a few modern pistols that are equally reliable, and require little maintenance. I've fired thousands of rounds through my Glock 21 and although I clean it after every time, I certainly don't have to. And I've never had a malfunction of any kind. Not one. Some guys I know clean theirs two or three times a year.

Now there are some rather unreliable brands out there still, so I imagine that's why the cliche still exists.

2
Freeposity lemmy.world Freeposity@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-04-27
#205 · Quote Reply

I can accept three tiddies, but bad atmospheric pressure is where I draw the line!

Well yeah, three tiddies are 50% more likely to keep me around than two.

2
fne8w2ah lemmy.world fne8w2ah@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-12
#206 · Quote Reply

I'mma about to ruin medical shows/scenes for y'all. And once you see this, you cannot unsee it. the source for all this is the 15 years I spent riding in the back of the bus as a medic. When you see a scene in the ER and a critical patient arrives, all the doctors go rushing into the exam room and start doing things and arguing about what to do. If we put this stupidity aside for a moment and r...

And isn't CPR deliberately depicted wrongly in movies and shows because the proper IRL CPR procedure risks breaking a person's ribs?

3
hirihit640 sh.itjust.works hirihit640@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2024-10-28
#207 · Quote Reply

You mean the Cyclops on xmen (marvel) or does DC also have a cyclops character that shoots a powerful laser?

My mistake yes cyclops from the MCU

2
AlteredEgo lemmy.ml AlteredEgo@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2024-01-26
#208 · Quote Reply

I find it unrealistic for any movie involving contact with aliens to not even consider how our and their microbial life would interact with each other. There should be a default rule of "oh you touched the alien? Ok, you will be the quarantine subject that we will monitor to make sure you haven't caught some slow developing disease that will inevitably kill any earth life in your vicinity becau...

Ironically it's canon in even Alien (1979) and even a truck driver / pilot knows it. "Oh you got in contact with an alien organism? Sorry can't let you on the ship."

For some reason the cowboy style of the Prometheus. The sad thing is they could have written around these bad tropes but chose not to.

6
Soupbreaker lemmy.world Soupbreaker@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-11
#209 · (edited) Quote Reply

I stopped before that, I think around the time the guy in the cool car banged some soccer mom. It was just a sign that we weren't exploring the human condition wither otherworldly tropes, but just throwing shit at the plot wall.

I mean, he doesn't actually bang her. But those scenes always grossed me out. I don't want to see adults even almost fucking high school kids in my kids-on-bikes sci-fi show. Maybe the Duffer brothers would say they were lampshading an older sexist trope by gender-flipping it, but that doesn't make it less repulsive.

4
ShyBeluga lemmy.zip ShyBeluga@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-10-12
#210 · Quote Reply

I just want a movie where somebody "says turn on the TV", and the main character does, and it's just halfway through an episode of The Big Bang Theory or something because who's tuned to the news channel.

Big Bang Theory is witty and funny. It’s my favorite show now. Am I old now?

2
orbitz lemmy.ca orbitz@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-30
#211 · Quote Reply

It's been way too long since I watched Raiders, but I remember it being great so I'll have to watch it again. That definitely sounds stupid. The only saving grace might be that U-boats, unlike modern submarines, very rarely went underwater. They had diesel engines that ran the engines on the surface and also charged batteries. They could use the batteries underwater, but they didn't last long. ...

It is a fun pulp adventure action movie, but if you expect realism you gotta stop there. As far as I know it was all inspired by old serial shows and pulp stories from magazines. Ya gotta just let certain stories be fun. Though as a geek it is fun to rag on their issues I know, have done that lots.

But yes seemed silly he hung on the uboat that long, I wondered about it growing up since was a regular watched movie, that was a long freaking trip to be hanging regardless of food service and comfort.

2
Bluewing lemmy.world Bluewing@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-10-25
#212 · Quote Reply

And isn't CPR deliberately depicted wrongly in movies and shows because the proper IRL CPR procedure risks breaking a person's ribs?

Oh, you break ribs when done right.

4
Bluewing lemmy.world Bluewing@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-10-25
#213 · Quote Reply

Is he going to make it, doc? cries

I don't know. Damn it Jim! I'm a piano player, not a Doctor!

3
Dnb lemmy.dbzer0.com Dnb@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-07-26
#214 · Quote Reply

28 Years Later felt like it was mostly a setup for The Bone Temple, which was a trip.

The ending broke me with how ridiculous it was. I should see bone Temple i suppose

2
Lovable Sidekick lemmy.world LovableSidekick@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-10-19
#215 · Quote Reply

I love the scene in (a movie, just realized I can talk about it without spoiling if I don't say what movie, those who have seen it will know), where there's an attempt to do a romance scam where they rob you when you get naked to have sex with the bait woman. He takes the other guy's gun, at which point the guy laughs and says it's only loaded with blanks. MC pauses for a second then shoots him...

I find it kind of cool that they portrayed blanks correctly, or at least more accurately than usual. The public has a misconception that shooting blanks is like shooting a cap gun.

4
Bluewing lemmy.world Bluewing@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-10-25
#216 · Quote Reply

But they will share all the details with any random supporter waiting for the procedure to be finished in the otherwise empty waiting room, right?

Oh yeah, that is so totally true. HIPPA doesn't apply to strangers in the hallway.

3
Dnb lemmy.dbzer0.com Dnb@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-07-26
#217 · Quote Reply

The TV show 24 killed me with how he was able to do much in an hour when it could easily have taken 30-1.5 hr just in travel time around cities like LA.

For anyone who doesn't know the show premise was each episode was 1 hr in a 24hr period where the main guy has to stop some kind of terrorist or otherwise crazy attack with dozens of sub plots and things he has to do per hour too. But somehow he travels across major cities in minutes.

9
Bieren lemmy.today Bieren@lemmy.today
Joined: 2026-03-01
#218 · Quote Reply

What kills me. The smart person, call them a leader in molecular biology. That can suddenly fly a space ship. Operate everything in said space ship. Write a computer program, in excel, to translate an alien species. Like come on dawg. I get it. You’re smart and make a fun movie. But the whole 1 person that is a fucking the expert in literally everything that happens is just getting old.

10
mefisdo_dot_info lemmy.ca mefisdo_dot_info@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2026-10-11
#219 · Quote Reply

I can relate to this. A movie asks for suspension of disbelief, and I am happy to grant that. But then it has to present a coherent world for which I suspended my disbelief. If it doesn't then I wasted my suspended disbelief and that's annoying.

15
Bieren lemmy.today Bieren@lemmy.today
Joined: 2026-03-01
#220 · Quote Reply

I stopped watching Stranger Things because in a show about demons from a parallel universe invading a small town, I couldn't get over a soccer mom breaking her friend out of a Russian prison camp. That broke the realism for me.

Season 1 is goat level of good. Goes off the rails from there. The whole 11 going wild thing and then the Russian thing were just not needed.

Not to mention the 76 years or whatever it took them to film it all. Those kids in the last season all looked like mid 20 year olds with a shit corpo job. Not high school age kids.

5
bertlewirth lemy.lol bertlewirth@lemy.lol
Joined: 2026-09-16
#221 · (edited) Quote Reply

Big Bang Theory is witty and funny. It’s my favorite show now. Am I old now?

TBBT is bottom of the barrel humour. It's meh at best. IMHO.

3
amgine lemmy.world amgine@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-30
#222 · Quote Reply

What kills me. The smart person, call them a leader in molecular biology. That can suddenly fly a space ship. Operate everything in said space ship. Write a computer program, in excel, to translate an alien species. Like come on dawg. I get it. You’re smart and make a fun movie. But the whole 1 person that is a fucking the expert in literally everything that happens is just getting old.

17
amgine lemmy.world amgine@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-30
#223 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

What I enjoy is watching poorly directed/acted shows or movies and stopping right after a cut. Pay attention, if they’re not the best actors, you can see them starting their lines or getting the gears going. This is especially apparent when there’s no sound. It’s ruined syndicated shows for me.

1
cravl slrpnk.net cravl@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2023-06-10
#224 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

If you think the Hulk is bad, don't even try to work out Ant-Man. Even if you use the "it's magic" argument (which IIRC Ant-Man's powers are not described that way), it still contradicts its own logic constantly.

1
Underwaterbob sh.itjust.works Underwaterbob@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-04
#225 · Quote Reply

Mission Impossible, the first remake with Tom Cruise. The final scene ruined the whole thing for me. He's hanging on the outside of a helicopter flying through a train tunnel chasing a train - which apparently wasn't improbable enough because he then blows up the helicopter and the explosion sends him flying safely onto the train.

I'm sorry, but that helicopter was made of metal and glass. Anything that blew it up is going to turn him into a fine mist. In another, cheesier action movie, fine! But the movie took itself so seriously otherwise that I just couldn't anymore.

4
Folstar lemmus.org Folstar@lemmus.org
Joined: 2026-03-24
#226 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

I have not seen that one, but people taking a bad situation an making it much worse for the dumbest reasons possible actually sounds painfully realistic.

2
Folstar lemmus.org Folstar@lemmus.org
Joined: 2026-03-24
#227 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

I don't know the official MCU explanation for the Hulk, but in the comics the lore goes to absolutely insane places and him gaining mass is incredibly tame in the grand scheme of things.

1
mlg lemmy.world mlg@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-29
#228 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

I don't know why people forget even the first moon missions had a quarentine trailer/chamber used by the astronauts for this exact reason.

They were pretty sure they weren't gonna find microbial life on the moon but they sure as hell weren't gonna take the risk in case there actually was.

5
mlg lemmy.world mlg@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-29
#229 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Haha I remember watching independence day for the first time and thinking "oh damn they're gonna infect the aliens with a disease" and then Jeff goes "computer virus" before tapping away with his laptop.

tbf though I consider that movie the king of blockbusters for the absolute massive list of wacky tacky bs that occurs pretty much the entire runtime of the film lol.

2
MilitantAtheist lemmy.world MilitantAtheist@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-02
#230 · Quote Reply

The TV show 24 killed me with how he was able to do much in an hour when it could easily have taken 30-1.5 hr just in travel time around cities like LA. For anyone who doesn't know the show premise was each episode was 1 hr in a 24hr period where the main guy has to stop some kind of terrorist or otherwise crazy attack with dozens of sub plots and things he has to do per hour too. But somehow h...

Yeah, but you still remember what it sounds like when the phones ring and the sound the clock makes.

5
Tattorack lemmy.world Tattorack@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-28
#231 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Speaking of medical dramas:

I was amazed how Stargate Atlantis got one medical procedure right over so many medical dramas I've seen.

Patient is in defib, so they get the defibrillator. Doesn't work, patient's heart stops. They take away the defibrillator and start doing chest compressions.

I was just... Woaw. This series plays so fast and loose with science. Didn't expect that.

4
Tattorack lemmy.world Tattorack@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-28
#232 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

28 Weeks Later is such an incredibly stupid, and also unnecessary, sequel.

The sequel turned the infected into regular zombies. The 28 Days Later, nobody was a zombie. They could actually die from getting shot, needed to eat to survive, and by the end they all starved to death.

None of the characters were monumentally stupid either. So many incredibly fucking stupid characters in 28 Weeks Later. I watched it once when I was a teenager and I remember essentially asking "Why would he do that!?" every 5 or 10 minutes.

3
arrow74 lemmy.zip arrow74@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-06-04
#233 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Miniscule compared to the work of the Christians

1
Tattorack lemmy.world Tattorack@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-28
#234 · Quote Reply

I don't nitpick over really minor things, like the wrong snakes and such. I can understand unrealistic silly if it makes sense for the movie.

What I can't stand are plots or situations that can only exist because the writers don't know what the fuck they're writing about, or lack any imagination in making plot reasons happen.

Battlefield Los Angeles is one of those movies I just can't fucking stand because of this.

Tap for spoiler
  • The aliens invade Earth because it's the only planet in the solar system with liquid water, and that's apparently very valuable.

Excuse me, but are you telling me an interstellar capable alien civilisation cannot melt ice? Do you have any idea how much water there is in the Kuiper Belt!? There are chunks of ice floating over there the size of countries.

Any alien could be mining the Kuiper Belt for a thousand years and we'd never notice. Nobody would have to commit so many resources to cunduct such a wasteful invasion of an inhabited planet with an amount of water that is a knee high puddle compared to everything that's available in space!

  • The alien technology is somehow... Modern and not very futuristic, and eventually get beaten after just a day or two of intense fighting.

So... The alien species can cross the stars. The alien species apparently has the technology to analyse Earth from light years away. They can not only detect liquid water on Earth from that distance, but also that there is a civilisation living there.

They have some pretty fucking granular information about Earth for observations made several light years away, and... that is the best they could do!? A two day failed invasion with a pitiful amount of troops and no orbital support?

They have the technology to fly through the depths of space and get mind bogglingly detailed information from so far away, and they invade land tiny force equipped with crap that functions almost worse than what we currently have!?

This species is written too stupid to have even made it to an interstellar level.

10
pishadoot sh.itjust.works pishadoot@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-07-05
#235 · Quote Reply

You're buying the wrong pistols then. You can throw a Glock in mid then run 800 rounds through it without cleaning, without jamming. And reloading a pistol is much easier than reloading a revolver. They also don't kick nearly as much as a revolver, making them far more accurate.

I shoot an average of 4000 rounds a month. I would bet a whole lot of money that I'm far more familiar with "pistols" in all types than you are.

Revolvers are pistols.

Their recoil is often less than a semi auto. It depends on so many factors that saying they have more or less recoil is a nonsense claim; it depends on your ammo and the mass of the gun, primarily.

Accuracy is the same. Sights matter. Build quality matters. Length of your barrel matters. It all matters.

You can throw a Ruger GP100 in the mud and I'd trust it any day over a Glock covered in mud. It's foolish to claim otherwise.

Glocks are great handguns. But they have malfunctions just the same, especially when you have mags with worn out springs like a lot of daily carry guns do because people pack the mags full and then leave them that way for years on end.

I'm not saying revolvers are better, I'm saying they have pros and cons and it's personal preference. Many people who obviously know more than you do think they're the best guns to carry when you need them most. I won't say I agree or disagree, just that I acknowledge the points, and I'm sharing them here because firearm knowledge is generally abysmal, even in countries where they're readily available.

1
wonderingwanderer sopuli.xyz wonderingwanderer@sopuli.xyz
Joined: 2025-12-31
#236 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Sure, if you can find enough razor cartridges. Armpits are too concave to use a straight razor on I would think.

Granted it is possible she did IPL or electrolysis before the downfall of society, so that is a potentially reasonable explanation

2
BenLeMan lemmy.world BenLeMan@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-15
#237 · Quote Reply

Haha I remember watching independence day for the first time and thinking "oh damn they're gonna infect the aliens with a disease" and then Jeff goes "computer virus" before tapping away with his laptop. tbf though I consider that movie the king of blockbusters for the absolute massive list of wacky tacky bs that occurs pretty much the entire runtime of the film lol.

It's wacky tacky alright. 😅

2
Bluewing lemmy.world Bluewing@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-10-25
#238 · Quote Reply

Speaking of medical dramas: I was amazed how Stargate Atlantis got one medical procedure right over so many medical dramas I've seen. Patient is in defib, so they get the defibrillator. Doesn't work, patient's heart stops. They take away the defibrillator and start doing chest compressions. I was just... Woaw. This series plays so fast and loose with science. Didn't expect that.

That's pretty close, but no cigar. You never remove the defib. Then you do 2 minutes more of compressions and then you re-analyze again. Wash rinse and repeat until you are relieved or someone with the authority to decide tells you to stop.

Now, if one of the characters is a medical doctor or the idiot script writer in this case, they were quasi military right, then those people can make a decision to stop CPR. But it would have been a more accurate scene if they just shown them starting CPR, doing a cut scene to everyone being exhausted and done. Or checking the body and seeing an obvious sign of death like lividity and not even starting. So still pretty poor writing.

The worst part is that it's so easy to get this stuff right. It's just simple things. not rocket surgery.

2
grrgyle slrpnk.net grrgyle@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-03-18
#239 · Quote Reply

Normalise removing your interest and presence from bullshit situations 👏🏻

6
Pollo_Jack lemmy.world Pollo_Jack@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-16
#240 · (edited) Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Don't you believe in fairies?

1
Corkyskog sh.itjust.works Corkyskog@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-12
#241 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Physics wasn't my best science, but wouldn't the recoil have to be equivalent? So if the bad guy gets thrown back 3 feet, the protagonist would also get thrown back about that amount?

2
dragonbringerx lemmy.world dragonbringerx@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-09-18
#242 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Honestly it depends on the revolver. Different revolvers do hold different amounts of ammo. I have seen heavier revolvers like .357 or .44 that hold anywhere from 5 to 6 shots. I have also seen light caliber revolvers like a .38 or .32 that holds 8 to even 12 shots. Of course, a 12 shot revolver is typically only a very light weight like the .32, and they tend to be very small guns. Thay being said, most movies don't show that. They show a guy with a huge ass gun that probably only hold 5 to 6 shots at best. Then again, very few shows or movies ever show guns accurately. The sound from shooting even a light caliber gun can deafening in an open space. The sound of a .357 is so loud its unbelievable.

1
merc sh.itjust.works merc@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-09
#243 · Quote Reply

Physics wasn't my best science, but wouldn't the recoil have to be equivalent? So if the bad guy gets thrown back 3 feet, the protagonist would also get thrown back about that amount?

Yeah, exactly. Newton's third law. If the person who was hit goes flying, an equivalent force had to be acting on the shooter. If that shooter is shooting a handgun, imagine just how much force is acting on their wrist.

1
merc sh.itjust.works merc@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-09
#244 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

Yeah, it makes a lot of sense to do a test dive right at the start.

A 12 inch gun on a sub is crazy. That's not just a gun from a battleship, that's one of the main guns from the battleship. That's a ridiculous amount of overkill for a merchant ship. If you wanted to ambush armoured enemy ships that's another matter. If you could successfully do that, it might not even matter if the gun only lasted a few shots. A sub is cheap compared to anything requiring a 12 inch gun. I'm surprised they got far enough with the program to actually test fire them.

1
merc sh.itjust.works merc@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-09
#245 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

You sure do what?

1
Canadian_Cabinet lemmy.ca Canadian_Cabinet@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-13
#246 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

The most egregious example of this that I can think of is in the final shootout of Commando, where Schwarzenegger's character fires hundreds of rounds without ever reloading once

2
ChickenLadyLovesLife lemmy.world ChickenLadyLovesLife@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-16
#247 · Quote Reply

Yeah, it makes a lot of sense to do a test dive right at the start. A 12 inch gun on a sub is crazy. That's not just a gun from a battleship, that's one of the main guns from the battleship. That's a ridiculous amount of overkill for a merchant ship. If you wanted to ambush armoured enemy ships that's another matter. If you could successfully do that, it might not even matter if the gun only la...

Since the gun could only be loaded while the sub was surfaced, it had to sink its target in one shot, which was unlikely to be the case against warships, even something small and unarmored like a destroyer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_M1_(1917)

1
merc sh.itjust.works merc@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-09
#248 · Quote Reply

Since the gun could only be loaded while the sub was surfaced, it had to sink its target in one shot, which was unlikely to be the case against warships, even something small and unarmored like a destroyer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_M1_(1917)

Good luck managing to hit a destroyer with a fixed gun.

I would imagine that if you did manage a hit though, it would be devastating. I don't think there were many ships that could shrug off hits from a 12 inch gun. Even if it didn't sink, it would probably be badly damaged, which might give the sub the opportunity to surface somewhere safe, reload, and shoot again.

1
pathief lemmy.world pathief@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-10
#249 · Quote Reply

What about a free and available parking spot in front of every location they're driving to?

2
HeyJoe lemmy.world HeyJoe@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-05
#250 · Quote Reply

What kills me. The smart person, call them a leader in molecular biology. That can suddenly fly a space ship. Operate everything in said space ship. Write a computer program, in excel, to translate an alien species. Like come on dawg. I get it. You’re smart and make a fun movie. But the whole 1 person that is a fucking the expert in literally everything that happens is just getting old.

I feel like your calling out Project Hail Mary. Is this what you are referring to?

1
HeyJoe lemmy.world HeyJoe@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-05
#251 · Quote Reply

I work in IT, don't get me started on things that don't make sense. I was genuinely shocked when I watched Mr. Robot and thought omg they actually tried!

1
Post Reply Page 5 of 6   Goto page « First 1 ... 3, 4, 5, 6 Last »

Back to top