RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Windows 11's New Media Player Uses 3.5x More RAM, Charges for Popular Video Codecs
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
tiramichu sh.itjust.works tiramichu@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-04
#52 · Quote Reply

Windows is the new Winrar.

WinRAR said it had a 40 day trial, but it actually never expired and you could continue using it forever for free. You never had to pay.

Which is why we have all the WinRAR memes.

Due to this, it was actually pretty goated, and remembered fondly by many.

18
mnemonicmonkeys sh.itjust.works mnemonicmonkeys@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-17
#53 · Quote Reply

Everyone saying "why not use VLC?" Because I have never liked its interface. MPC BE though... That is my jam.

I wonder if people have made mods to zhuzh up how the interface looks

1
Billegh lemmy.world bhamlin@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#54 · Quote Reply

Question: how does VLC get away with playing these proprietary codecs without compensating the owners of them?

Short answer: many have no licensing requirements for playback, only encoding. Sales are easy when you have a good codec that everyone can watch.

8
Aceticon lemmy.dbzer0.com Aceticon@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-12-06
#55 · Quote Reply

do they have the concept of intangible assets?

Something only becomes an intellectual property (intangible) asset if there is a law that says that said specific kind of thing can be intellectual property - the whole domain is an entirely artificial creation and there is no such thing as natural intellectual property.

So whilst French and EU do have the concept of intangible assets, it's irrelevant here because software patents aren't intellectual property according that those laws and hence are not "assets" and are thus not covered by such laws.

2
Blue_Morpho lemmy.world Blue_Morpho@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-11-14
#56 · Quote Reply

ffmpeg binaries from pretty much anyone should have libmp3lame baked-in. the format was 'freed' from the last patent in 2017.

That's good to know that it's been updated but the reason it wasn't in the default binaries until the patent expired was because "it's free" isn't a defense from being sued by a patent holder.

Vlc including patented codecs is getting away with it despite the sword hanging over the project. Ffmpeg prefers to be safe because many free OpenSource projects have been shut down by patent holders.

1
Hueristic_Autistic lemmy.world Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-06-06
#57 · Quote Reply

Ehmmmm.... Vlc?

7
SabinStargem lemmy.today SabinStargem@lemmy.today
Joined: 2025-03-15
#58 · Quote Reply

WinRAR said it had a 40 day trial, but it actually never expired and you could continue using it forever for free. You never had to pay. Which is why we have all the WinRAR memes. Due to this, it was actually pretty goated, and remembered fondly by many.

I honestly would buy a $300 copy of Windows Enterprise, provided it didn't have adware and other invasive things. Unfortunately, the last time I bought a premium Windows was back when Windows 7 Ultimate roamed the world.

These days, I just pirate a copy of Enterprise via RUFUS, and use ShutUp10 to kill whatever nastiness that Microsoft is up to. That sucks. I want to just buy a perfect Windows and get on with my day.

2
pipikia lemmy.zip pipikia@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-05-26
#59 · Quote Reply

Does Microsoft not have anyone capable of reverse engineering these drivers too? Isn’t it in their best interest to also broaden compatibility?

What those drivers do is patented in the US. See MPEG licensing. VLC is based in the EU which does not have a mechanism for software patents that do not solve a physical problem (moving bits around isn't patentable there) so they can avoid issues. Microsoft, Corel, and Nero would not be able to do that, they have assets in the US, even if it would only be a bank account.

I would not be surprised if codec licensing would not allow shipping with old and open codecs like MJPEG, Theora and AV1 with an addon for the proprietary codecs.

2
Post Reply Page 2 of 2   Goto page « First 1, 2
Back to top