RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
For Better... Mother
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
JohnnyEnzyme piefed.social JohnnyEnzyme@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-11
Quote

For Better Or For Worse tribute-edit, by Mike Peters of "Mother Goose & Grimm," 1997.

Not sure how many here remember these. FBoFW ended about 10yrs later, after a ~30yr run. It was one of those rare-ish strips that aged the characters naturally. MG&G is still going strong.

From the Great Switcheroo project.

37   Original
tyranny crazypeople.online tyranny@crazypeople.online
Joined: 2026-06-11
#2 · Quote Reply

great edit, great fourth wall break, great art style, holding the speech bubble in hand makes the joke nice and clear. my only gripe would be that it takes 3 panels of confusion before the payoff, which feels like a long stretch

4
JohnnyEnzyme Moderator JohnnyEnzyme@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-11
#3 · Quote Reply

great edit, great fourth wall break, great art style, holding the speech bubble in hand makes the joke nice and clear. my only gripe would be that it takes 3 panels of confusion before the payoff, which feels like a long stretch

my only gripe would be that it takes 3 panels of confusion before the payoff, which feels like a long stretch

I'm a fan of tension-building, so that actually works for me. It's reasonably witty / amusing dialogue too, IMO. If it wasn't, then yeah, 3 panels would probably feel long.

Also, I'm thinking that the authentic FBoFW typically ran 4 panels, so it's also a nod to that.

4
tyranny crazypeople.online tyranny@crazypeople.online
Joined: 2026-06-11
#4 · Quote Reply

my only gripe would be that it takes 3 panels of confusion before the payoff, which feels like a long stretch I'm a fan of tension-building, so that actually works for me. It's reasonably witty / amusing dialogue too, IMO. If it wasn't, then yeah, 3 panels would probably feel long. Also, I'm thinking that the authentic FBoFW typically ran 4 panels, so it's also a nod to that.

i think if it were more clear from the humans' faces that they're perplexed and alarmed by the words coming out of their mouths, it'd work more for me. i hear your point though, it's nice to stick to an established formula, especially when you're doing something different conceptually

2
JohnnyEnzyme Moderator JohnnyEnzyme@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-11
#5 · Quote Reply

i think if it were more clear from the humans' faces that they're perplexed and alarmed by the words coming out of their mouths, it'd work more for me. i hear your point though, it's nice to stick to an established formula, especially when you're doing something different conceptually

Funny, they look plenty perplexed & alarmed over here compared to their normal faces, but that's as a long-time reader. I could see for less-familiar readers that they just look kind of blank-faced.

Whatever. We each have our own lens.

2
shweddy lemmy.world shweddy@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-03-21
#6 · Quote Reply

What's the comic with the old Lady and the dog?

2
JohnnyEnzyme Moderator JohnnyEnzyme@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-11
#7 · Quote Reply

What's the comic with the old Lady and the dog?

This:
https://www.gocomics.com/mother-goose-and-grimm

4
FauxPseudo Moderator FauxPseudo@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-09
#8 · Quote Reply

This could be my house when my wife is having a bad day.

3
Mnem667 sh.itjust.works Mnem667@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-15
#9 · Quote Reply

Man, I haven't thought about either of these strips in decades far, far too long.

6
tyranny crazypeople.online tyranny@crazypeople.online
Joined: 2026-06-11
#10 · Quote Reply

Funny, they look plenty perplexed & alarmed over here compared to their normal faces, but that's as a long-time reader. I could see for less-familiar readers that they just look kind of blank-faced. Whatever. We each have our own lens.

i hear you, ive never encountered the comic before, but i imagine I'm not the target audience of a long-running strip like this

1
Swedneck discuss.tchncs.de Swedneck@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-10
#11 · Quote Reply

great edit, great fourth wall break, great art style, holding the speech bubble in hand makes the joke nice and clear. my only gripe would be that it takes 3 panels of confusion before the payoff, which feels like a long stretch

i kinda like it, it becomes its own joke a-la heathcliff's absolute nonsense presented without clarification

2
Post Reply
Back to top