RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
The Britannica entry for the Fediverse is really good
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
supersquirrel lemmy.ca supersquirrel@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2026-08-07
Quote

It isn't that surprising but it is somewhat surprising.

142   Original
Zedstrian sopuli.xyz Zedstrian@sopuli.xyz
Joined: 2025-03-30
#2 · (edited) Quote Reply

fediverse, decentralized group of social media platforms in which each independent platform can interact freely with any other platform that is part of the group.

Great that they have an article on it, though their formatting the start of each article like a dictionary entry is a bit odd compared to Wikipedia.

If it were a Wikipedia article, it would probably need some copyediting to give it a more encyclopedic tone along with in-line citations.

17
rumba lemmy.zip rumba@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2024-09-24
#3 · Quote Reply

fediverse, decentralized group of social media platforms in which each independent platform can interact freely with any other platform that is part of the group. Great that they have an article on it, though their formatting the start of each article like a dictionary entry is a bit odd compared to Wikipedia. If it were a Wikipedia article, it would probably need some copyediting to give it a ...

Man, that "can" is doing a fuck of a lot of heavy lifting. lemmy, piefed are 100% when you start going pixelfed or loops, or mastodon the compatibility matrix stops looking like that nice spiderweb.

you're lucky if you can even finger a user between systems

12
Skullgrid lemmy.world Skullgrid@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-29
#4 · Quote Reply

Man, that "can" is doing a fuck of a lot of heavy lifting. lemmy, piefed are 100% when you start going pixelfed or loops, or mastodon the compatibility matrix stops looking like that nice spiderweb. you're lucky if you can even finger a user between systems

you’re lucky if you can even finger a user between systems

I'm sure the gals at the blahaj zone are up for it

15
OpenStars discuss.online OpenStars@discuss.online
Joined: 2023-12-31
#5 · Quote Reply

Meta's Threads is also working toward ActivityPub compatibility, which would significantly expand the fediverse user base.

Um... fuck no, please and thank you!

36
CombatWombat feddit.online CombatWombat@feddit.online
Joined: 2025-09-09
#6 · Quote Reply

Meta's Threads is also working toward ActivityPub compatibility, which would significantly expand the fediverse user base. Um... fuck no, please and thank you!

The bad news is: you can already follow accounts bidirectionally between Threads and Mastodon. The good news is: Meta did the bare minimum and seems to have stopped development.

33
schnurrito discuss.tchncs.de schnurrito@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-24
#7 · Quote Reply

How is the fediverse different from traditional social media?

The fediverse is a decentralized network of social media platforms that freely interact, unlike traditional social media.

I have a bit of a problem with the term "traditional social media".

The earliest popular form of social media was Usenet. The first one I ever used was web forums (run on phpBB or similar software). Those have a lot more "tradition" than Facebook or Twitter or TikTok, so why are they calling the latter three (deviations from the decentralized "tradition" of the Internet) "traditional social media"?! Is it just that they're the first form of social media that the authors of that article ever used?

7
dusk piefed.social dusk@piefed.social
Joined: 2026-10-09
#8 · Quote Reply

eNPV63jSxfdwoKw.png

I recommend uBlacklist to correct this.

5
9point6 lemmy.world 9point6@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-12
#9 · (edited) Quote Reply

How is the fediverse different from traditional social media? The fediverse is a decentralized network of social media platforms that freely interact, unlike traditional social media. I have a bit of a problem with the term "traditional social media". The earliest popular form of social media was Usenet. The first one I ever used was web forums (run on phpBB or similar software). Those have a l...

Those were not considered social media in their heyday as the term was created after them specifically for sites where a user would maintain a non-anonymous profile, post content about themselves and curating a feed based on other profiles followed.

Forums and Usenet could be considered proto-social-media perhaps given they were clear precursors to it

8
schnurrito discuss.tchncs.de schnurrito@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-24
#10 · Quote Reply

Those were not considered social media in their heyday as the term was created after them specifically for sites where a user would maintain a non-anonymous profile, post content about themselves and curating a feed based on other profiles followed. Forums and Usenet could be considered proto-social-media perhaps given they were clear precursors to it

Of course. I find "social media" a suboptimal term anyway. A good term for the concept is the "participatory Internet".

But if we are going to use it, then it's just media that is produced by society at large as opposed to paid journalists or authors. Meaning Usenet is social media.

2
zip lemmy.blahaj.zone zip@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2023-11-21
#11 · Quote Reply

you’re lucky if you can even finger a user between systems I'm sure the gals at the blahaj zone are up for it

Can confirm. Finger me between systems, bby!

7
als lemmy.blahaj.zone als@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2023-10-25
#12 · Quote Reply

Unlike X (formerly Twitter) or Facebook, which remain in business by profiting from consumers’ personal information, the fediverse aims to give users privacy and an ad-free interface.

22
bandanawearingbanana lemmy.world bandanawearingbanana@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-03
#13 · Quote Reply

fediverse, decentralized group of social media platforms in which each independent platform can interact freely with any other platform that is part of the group. Great that they have an article on it, though their formatting the start of each article like a dictionary entry is a bit odd compared to Wikipedia. If it were a Wikipedia article, it would probably need some copyediting to give it a ...

Tbh I never understood the Lemmy users can interact with all other platforms that share the same protocol.

It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right?

1
hexagonwin lemmy.today hexagonwin@lemmy.today
Joined: 2026-02-07
#14 · Quote Reply

Tbh I never understood the Lemmy users can interact with all other platforms that share the same protocol. It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right?

It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right?

afaik you can

1
majster lemmy.zip majster@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-06-26
#15 · Quote Reply

Tbh I never understood the Lemmy users can interact with all other platforms that share the same protocol. It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right?

From mastodon viewing lemmy stuff is nice enough. It would be great if you could seamlessly crosspost and share between platforms.

3
bandanawearingbanana lemmy.world bandanawearingbanana@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-03
#16 · Quote Reply

It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right? afaik you can

how?

1
INeedMana piefed.zip INeedMana@piefed.zip
Joined: 2025-07-03
#17 · Quote Reply

Tbh I never understood the Lemmy users can interact with all other platforms that share the same protocol. It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right?

Lemmy and history, no. On Lemmy you can see comments from Mastodon and posts (toot with a Lemmy community pinged inside. Which is rarely done but happens). But not the toots themselves
Piefed now allows to directly follow accounts (similar to Mastodon, Friendica, etc) and you can start getting the new toots after following an account https://piefed.zip/c/microblogs

5
hexagonwin lemmy.today hexagonwin@lemmy.today
Joined: 2026-02-07
#18 · Quote Reply

how?

ehh.. just tested and it doesn't seem to work.. somehow i remembered it working but maybe i was mistaken

sorry for the misinformation

1
rumba lemmy.zip rumba@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2024-09-24
#19 · Quote Reply

ehh.. just tested and it doesn't seem to work.. somehow i remembered it working but maybe i was mistaken sorry for the misinformation

Yeah, I keep trying the different things. We're really not using the fediverse for all it's capable of.

We can generally see all the users on all the federated systems, but none of their old content, a limited number of systems can follow other systems and see new stuff.

I'd really like to see being able to log into pixelfed.social as rumba@lemmy.zip, post images there (and in loops.video) and reference them in my mastodon and lemmy posts.

All the interoperability is threadbare.

2
Lady Butterfly she/her reddthat.com LadyButterfly@reddthat.com
Joined: 2025-07-04
#20 · Quote Reply

Lemmy really is growing and I love that we're part of that

5
OpenStars discuss.online OpenStars@discuss.online
Joined: 2023-12-31
#21 · Quote Reply

The bad news is: you can already follow accounts bidirectionally between Threads and Mastodon. The good news is: Meta did the bare minimum and seems to have stopped development.

You can but iirc it takes quite a bit of bidirectional effort to enable that. Thankfully!

2
Bahnd Rollard lemmy.world Bahnd@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-26
#22 · Quote Reply

The bad news is: you can already follow accounts bidirectionally between Threads and Mastodon. The good news is: Meta did the bare minimum and seems to have stopped development.

Back when they started on that, we were worried they were going to kill ActivityPub like how Netscape got killed by IE durring the browser wars. EEE (Embrace, Expande, Eliminate), adopt the protocol, expand its capabilities while including propriatary portions of code, and lock the competition out when market saturation is achieved.

The issue is that fedivers residents are a bunch of tech-literate weirdos and called this bullshit the second the news dropped, and are 100% the type of people who make forks as soon as something like that would actually happen. Piefed being the perfect example, this part of the internet is perfectly fine just picking up their things and making something else (and we love it here for that).

11
mesa piefed.social mesamunefire@piefed.social
Joined: 2024-12-27
#23 · Quote Reply

Back when they started on that, we were worried they were going to kill ActivityPub like how Netscape got killed by IE durring the browser wars. EEE (Embrace, Expande, Eliminate), adopt the protocol, expand its capabilities while including propriatary portions of code, and lock the competition out when market saturation is achieved. The issue is that fedivers residents are a bunch of tech-liter...

Yep a lot of us built stuff like this before and will probably do it again.

6
mesa piefed.social mesamunefire@piefed.social
Joined: 2024-12-27
#24 · Quote Reply

ehh.. just tested and it doesn't seem to work.. somehow i remembered it working but maybe i was mistaken sorry for the misinformation

piefed is working on it at the moment. I can see some stuff working. Following/posts that make it here/etc.. its coming along pretty quick!

1
Jupiter Rowland sh.itjust.works JupiterRowland@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-25
#25 · Quote Reply

Tbh I never understood the Lemmy users can interact with all other platforms that share the same protocol. It's not like I can view a Mastodon user's history on Lemny, right?

Lemmy is all about groups. It doesn't have any way to connect to and interact with single users.

Mastodon, on the contrary, is all about single users following single users. It has no support for groups whatsoever. Mastodon users can follow Lemmy communities, yes. They can reply to posts, but in a very Mastodon way (automatic mentions, they'll probably insert hashtags etc.). Seeing (almost) the entire conversation is the default on Lemmy and extremely tedious and anything but straight-forward on Mastodon. And starting a new thread in a Lemmy community from Mastodon is difficult, nobody knows how to do it right, and whoever tries it will clash with Lemmy's culture.

Stuff like Friendica or Hubzilla is somewhat more general-purpose. It can do both. But I've yet to see a Lemmy user subscribe to a Friendica group or a Hubzilla forum (the opposite does work).

1
Jupiter Rowland sh.itjust.works JupiterRowland@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-25
#26 · Quote Reply

The bad news is: you can already follow accounts bidirectionally between Threads and Mastodon. The good news is: Meta did the bare minimum and seems to have stopped development.

Also, Threads has introduced extremely strict rules for servers that want to federate.

Entire Fediverse server applications are incapable of following all these rules, either technologically or by concept.

For example, IIRC, Threads demanded a full public timeline. Hubzilla, (streams) and Forte do have that feature in code. But it's intentionally turned off server-wide by default, and there's a very good reason for this and for just about no serious admins of public servers ever turning it on.

3
klu9 piefed.social klu9@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-04
#27 · Quote Reply

First I've ever heard of Soundstorm, which apparently hasn't been updated in 7 years.

https://github.com/weathermen/soundstorm

3
nomy lemmy.zip nomy@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2024-12-06
#28 · (edited) Quote Reply

Yeah, I keep trying the different things. We're really not using the fediverse for all it's capable of. We can generally see all the users on all the federated systems, but none of their old content, a limited number of systems can follow other systems and see new stuff. I'd really like to see being able to log into pixelfed.social as rumba@lemmy.zip, post images there (and in loops.video) and ...

This kind of stuff is the coolest thing about the fediverse and ActivityPub to me.

All the things you mentioned are possible in theory but the tools and infrastructure to do it haven't been created.

2
CoconutLove lemmy.today CoconutLove@lemmy.today
Joined: 2024-03-23
#29 · Quote Reply

Lemmy really is growing and I love that we're part of that

Where do you see evidence of that? I thought monthly active users has only dropped since peaking after the Reddit API debacle.

1
rumba lemmy.zip rumba@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2024-09-24
#30 · Quote Reply

This kind of stuff is the coolest thing about the fediverse and ActivityPub to me. All the things you mentioned are possible in theory but the tools and infrastructure to do it haven't been created.

Yeah, It's got some great bones. Would have been good if everyone had some interop best standards or even a skeleton framework, but i don't want my money back :)

2
sem lemmy.blahaj.zone sem@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2024-06-09
#31 · Quote Reply

"Mostly Harmless"

3
Rose piefed.social umbraroze@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-06
#32 · Quote Reply

Also, Threads has introduced extremely strict rules for servers that want to federate. Entire Fediverse server applications are incapable of following all these rules, either technologically or by concept. For example, IIRC, Threads demanded a full public timeline. Hubzilla, (streams) and Forte do have that feature in code. But it's intentionally turned off server-wide by default, and there's a...

Threads has introduced extremely strict rules for servers that want to federate.

That's hilarious, considering just as soon as this whole Threads fediverse integration project was announced, a whole bunch of prominent fediverse hosts joined up and blocked them en masse. Like, fuck it, we're not talking to Facebook, nope nope nope. (Turbo Based.) (Check your Mastodon instance. Chances are they're still blocking threads.net.)

1
Post Reply
Back to top