RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Tim Sweeney: "Besides taking 30%, they’re [Valve] also taking a potentially even larger fraction of developers’ revenue and livelihood by undermining their business with these AI hate campaigns."
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
Jerkface (any/all) lemmy.ca jerkface@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-06
#52 · (edited) Quote Reply

I meant market in the real sense not the American polemical form. A real market-driven price/cut is determined by supply and demand, the 30% figure was chosen by some American oligarchs that Valve decided to copy. Have you ever wondered why it's not 29.1% or 34.5% and the 30% figure never changes (other than than for well connected insiders?). How can market driven price never change, especiall...

have you ever wondered why no one can provide the services Valve does for cheaper than Valve does? Is it because of their famously anticompetitive practices, their notorious lobbying and threats to politicians, their strong-arm manipulation of vendors against each other? Perhaps they have some other method of defeating market forces?

-2
Jerkface (any/all) lemmy.ca jerkface@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-06
#53 · Quote Reply

I did buy hl2 on disc and was furious when I realised I HAD to create an online account to play the game that I had physical discs for.

Meanwhile you ran it on Windows. So obviously you didn't really care about being manipulated and fucked up the ass dry.

5
atrielienz lemmy.world atrielienz@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-05
#54 · (edited) Quote Reply

The real crime is that Valve requires price parity when you independently (no Steam keys) sell your game on a different store, as well as the Steam store. ("Most Favored Nation" clause.) It means that developers are allowed to pocket the profits if a game is sold on a store that has a lower percentage cut, but they aren't allowed to share the lower cost with the customer, because that could enc...

The real crime is that Valve requires price parity when you independently (no Steam keys) sell your game on a different store, as well as the Steam store.

They don't. Only if you are selling steam keys do they require price parity and only for steam key sales. You cannot sell a Steam key for less than you sell your game on Steam for. You can sell a non-Steam game key on other store fronts for any price you want.

This is what is being alleged in court by only a handful of developers but there are countless examples of the exact opposite thing being true.

11
schroedingersKoala piefed.ca schroedingersKoala@piefed.ca
Joined: 2026-02-05
#55 · Quote Reply

Good grief, Tim Sweeney is such an insufferable cunt.

48
baines lemmy.cafe baines@lemmy.cafe
Joined: 2024-10-26
#56 · Quote Reply

It's the eternal dilemma for game devs. They loathe the 30% cut (even though it's the same for every console, except you don't have any choice there) but at the same time steam does offer discoverability and platform features the devs and gamers love. I would have loved if Epic could compete with steam, but they instead chose to just throw money at gamers instead.

which just proves the overhead is reasoable

also pretty sure there are programs for true indie devs to reduce that price

1
baines lemmy.cafe baines@lemmy.cafe
Joined: 2024-10-26
#57 · (edited) Quote Reply

Way more than 80 games are being released. It not 2 decades ago anymore where a decent indie title was enough to get you noticed. Biggest challenge now isn't even the 30% cut but just people even knowing your game exists with the massively low barrier to games now. You aren't just competing against triple a titles, but every other aspiring indie dev hoping to make the next Balatro. Its a plus n...

all the actual good games on steam seem to do fine

i want anyone saying their game isn’t getting a fair shake on steam to post it

if it’s actually not trash i’ll buy it

1
frongt lemmy.zip frongt@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-07-31
#58 · Quote Reply

have you ever wondered why no one can provide the services Valve does for cheaper than Valve does? Is it because of their famously anticompetitive practices, their notorious lobbying and threats to politicians, their strong-arm manipulation of vendors against each other? Perhaps they have some other method of defeating market forces?

First mover advantage is the biggest reason.

But they've been able to maintain it just by not being shitty.

2
Confused_Emus lemmy.dbzer0.com Confused_Emus@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-07-19
#59 · Quote Reply

Are you running DNS blocklists?

I am running pi-hole. Seems strange that an archive site would be blocked.

1
87Six lemmy.zip 87Six@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-09-19
#60 · Quote Reply

Man if I were Steam's PR guy I would nor resist making fun of Sweeney all day long.

13
myyass lemmy.world myyass@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-09-02
#61 · Quote Reply

"Get nothing out of it?" Go ahead and spin up a store front that processes payments with every major channel, then come back to me in a decade when you've got that up and I'll give you your next task. Could just as easily argue it's Valve who isn't getting anything for your ten shovelware asset flip titles getting no sales, but they still have to pay for your overhead.

If you want to kiss valves' ass, be my guest. A company with 300 or so employees making a 3-4 billion profit last year is the same as Uber. Everyone's just a contractor and should be happy they use the platform. I'm not arguing if walmart or amazon is better. They both suck and they're stores. Valve has a nice history of suck as well as all the rest, everyone turns a blind eye to this. So I'm not going to pretend they're the good guys.

-2
dan1101 lemmy.world dan1101@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-12
#62 · Quote Reply

Man if I were Steam's PR guy I would nor resist making fun of Sweeney all day long.

They don't have to, Valve can do nothing and Sweeney keeps making himself look like a whiny idiot.

22
NoForwadSlashS piefed.social NoForwadSlashS@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-07-09
#63 · Quote Reply

Stop literally taking my money by making me work hard on my project.

19
supersquirrel lemmy.ca supersquirrel@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2026-08-07
#64 · Quote Reply

What a mega loser....

32
Die4Ever retrolemmy.com Die4Ever@retrolemmy.com
Joined: 2024-05-06
#65 · (edited) Quote Reply

He's so jealous of Steam you can smell it.

IDK why, he has plenty of money lol

6
Die4Ever retrolemmy.com Die4Ever@retrolemmy.com
Joined: 2024-05-06
#66 · (edited) Quote Reply

Good grief, Tim Sweeney is such an insufferable cunt.

It's too bad, I really like his early work. Jill of the Jungle, Epic Pinball, Jazz the Jackrabbit, Tyrian, all the Unreal Tournament games, Unreal Engine 1/2/3

14
eneff discuss.tchncs.de eneff@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-13
#67 · Quote Reply

I am running pi-hole. Seems strange that an archive site would be blocked.

I've heard some things about some of these archive sites using visitor connections to carry out DDoS attacks. Couldn't find anything with a quick search, but it's the reason some threadiverse instances ban links to these sites outright.

3
dubs lemmy.dbzer0.com dubs@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-08-17
#68 · Quote Reply

Fuck around and find out. He fucks around and still doesn't find out.

Having too much money insulates you from having to find out

6
Smaile lemmy.ca Smaile@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2026-01-28
#69 · Quote Reply

IDK why, he has plenty of money lol

Greed

13
copygirl lemmy.blahaj.zone copygirl@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2023-06-12
#70 · Quote Reply

The real crime is that Valve requires price parity when you independently (no Steam keys) sell your game on a different store, as well as the Steam store. They don't. Only if you are selling steam keys do they require price parity and only for steam key sales. You cannot sell a Steam key for less than you sell your game on Steam for. You can sell a non-Steam game key on other store fronts for a...

They must've changed their tone recently, because I've read an actual leaked court document, and the Valve representative / employee states (very defensively) that this is what they did. There's accounts of developers confirming this as well, including apparently in the (secret?) contract you sign when you sign up as a developer with Steam.

-1
BillyTheKid2 lemmy.ca BillyTheKid2@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2025-11-03
#71 · Quote Reply

They don't have to, Valve can do nothing and Sweeney keeps making himself look like a whiny idiot.

Classic Valve strategy:
Do nothing
Win.
Profit.
GabeN buys new megayatch

19
kurcatovium piefed.social kurcatovium@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-19
#72 · Quote Reply

What a mega loser....

You might even say he's an epic loser...

19
zod000 lemmy.dbzer0.com zod000@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2025-08-12
#73 · Quote Reply

Epic is 0% up to $1 million and 12% after. Microsoft store is 5% if it's through your website and 15% if it's through the app. GoG is 30% Google Play store is 30% after 1 million Why lie?

30% used to be the standard, all consoles took 30%, Apple and Google took 30%, and all the PC game storefronts did. Sweeney doesn't give a shit about saving anyone money but himself. He's been on a decade long crusade to avoid paying these fees and will say whatever he can to make them go away or get lower.

4
radiouser crazypeople.online radiouser@crazypeople.online
Joined: 2025-04-23
#74 · Quote Reply

Yeah most people don't remember being forced to get steam to play cs. And the fun of going from 150fps to sub 30fps. Nor buying HL2 day one and having to wait 3 weeks to play it--I should have just bought the cd version at the local store sigh

I remember... they killed WON.

3
bigbangdangler reddthat.com bigbangdangler@reddthat.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#75 · Quote Reply

Tim, you're just dumb. You think people don't see right through your business-brain bullshit, and it makes you look even dumber. Sit down and shut up.

13
Krudler lemmy.world Krudler@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-07
#76 · Quote Reply

If you ever somehow falter, and believe that you should listen to this man... Remember that he went on the record very recently saying that if a game is to be successful, it must launch on their competitor's platform, Steam.

6
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#77 · Quote Reply

Greed

And his fear of inadequacy, of course.

6
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#78 · Quote Reply

A lot of us don't hate AI. Maybe he should ask AI for advice on not sounding like a dumbass Step 1. Devs who use AI don't boast about how little effort they put into their products by using it

A lot of us don't hate AI.

FWIW, "a lot of us" also don't hate the oligarchs & their sycophants enough, either. I'm betting that Venn is a circle.

2
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#79 · Quote Reply

That’s an improvement.

You're mistaking him for the goodest boy. ☝🏼

2
atrielienz lemmy.world atrielienz@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-05
#80 · Quote Reply

They must've changed their tone recently, because I've read an actual leaked court document, and the Valve representative / employee states (very defensively) that this is what they did. There's accounts of developers confirming this as well, including apparently in the (secret?) contract you sign when you sign up as a developer with Steam.

Link the leaked court document.

4
steelplatedmech piefed.ca steelplatedmech@piefed.ca
Joined: 2026-07-22
#81 · Quote Reply

Only restriction I know for this scheme is you can't sell the keys outside steam for less than you sell on Steam. Otherwise you can just undercut them while still using their services

But easy to get around by discounting it for less than the listed price. Isthereanydeals and gg.deals is a great source for historical price trends across multiple storefronts from official to approved key selling stores.

2
steelplatedmech piefed.ca steelplatedmech@piefed.ca
Joined: 2026-07-22
#82 · Quote Reply

If you want to kiss valves' ass, be my guest. A company with 300 or so employees making a 3-4 billion profit last year is the same as Uber. Everyone's just a contractor and should be happy they use the platform. I'm not arguing if walmart or amazon is better. They both suck and they're stores. Valve has a nice history of suck as well as all the rest, everyone turns a blind eye to this. So I'm n...

You say it like it is bad, but isn't it actually a good thing that a company chooses the profitable route over an unsustainable model that requires infinite growth and leads to constant employee turnover?

Practice of running companies at a loss and only being kept afloat because of VC money seems to make everything worse. Company that is losing money while those at top rakes money seems to be what makes competitors harder as it requires huge outside capital to survive long enough for over a decade losing money.

4
blartcap_ lemmy.dbzer0.com blartcap_@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-07-03
#83 · Quote Reply

Can't wait for all those people whose entire argument is "Oh yeah well Steam takes a 30% cut" to add this to their arsenal.

1
blartcap_ lemmy.dbzer0.com blartcap_@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-07-03
#84 · Quote Reply

So I really hate epic. And the Ai BS. And this moron. But I have an unpopular opinion on steam/valve. I will say, a couple friends are game devs and they have a very negative outlook on the 30% cut. One told me that there's something like 80 games a month added to steam and that most have a 1-5% success rate. In other words, most of these game developers are being milked by steam(punny coffee j...

The only two storefronts that don't charge 30% base cut are EGS and Microsoft Store.

3
myyass lemmy.world myyass@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-09-02
#85 · Quote Reply

You say it like it is bad, but isn't it actually a good thing that a company chooses the profitable route over an unsustainable model that requires infinite growth and leads to constant employee turnover? Practice of running companies at a loss and only being kept afloat because of VC money seems to make everything worse. Company that is losing money while those at top rakes money seems to be w...

Most people that go into making games don't go into it for profit. Do you think my friend went to make a Halo game because it was to make money or because it was fun to have a lan party?

0
farmgineer nord.pub farmgineer@nord.pub
Joined: 2026-04-25
#86 · Quote Reply

I hate most things people would call 'AI' for a variety of reasons. Hiding its usage in something just means I'm not going to trust your platform at all, not suddenly stop caring about the issue. It's a problem steam has as well with not properly enforcing meaningful disclosure or a vetting process. Hell, the recent event didn't even have a filter for AI so I spent no money on steam, either.

6
Nik282000 lemmy.ca nik282000@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-08-22
#87 · Quote Reply

It's too bad, I really like his early work. Jill of the Jungle, Epic Pinball, Jazz the Jackrabbit, Tyrian, all the Unreal Tournament games, Unreal Engine 1/2/3

Tyrian and UT:GOTY were two of the greatest games to come out of the 90's.

4
NigelFrobisher aussie.zone NigelFrobisher@aussie.zone
Joined: 2023-08-07
#88 · Quote Reply

Instead of whining like a loser, why isn’t this guy trying to assassinate Gabe via various comical means to trigger whatever “Ready Player One” succession bullshit he has left in place to decide who is worthy to take stewardship of Steam?

1
kestrel7_7 lemmy.world kestrel7_7@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-07-31
#89 · Quote Reply

Most people that go into making games don't go into it for profit. Do you think my friend went to make a Halo game because it was to make money or because it was fun to have a lan party?

Do you think my friend went to make a Halo game because it was to make money or because it was fun to have a lan party?

Do you think Bungie initially developed Halo for fun, or to make money?

2
kestrel7_7 lemmy.world kestrel7_7@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-07-31
#90 · Quote Reply

I've heard some things about some of these archive sites using visitor connections to carry out DDoS attacks. Couldn't find anything with a quick search, but it's the reason some threadiverse instances ban links to these sites outright.

https://techcrunch.com/2026/02/21/wikipedia-blacklists-archive-today-after-alleged-ddos-attack/

2
Bosht lemmy.world Bosht@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-02-22
#91 · Quote Reply

Out of touch cunt with no pulse on what gamers want whines. More at 7. Fuck off.

6
myyass lemmy.world myyass@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-09-02
#92 · Quote Reply

Do you think my friend went to make a Halo game because it was to make money or because it was fun to have a lan party? Do you think Bungie initially developed Halo for fun, or to make money?

Honestly to fulfill the dream of making video games. It's kind of how blizzard didn't have requirements of a college degree, instead a portfolio.

1
TwodogsFighting lemdro.id TwodogsFighting@lemdro.id
Joined: 2025-07-14
#93 · Quote Reply

Fuck off with your slop, Sweeney.

20
thecryptickler reddthat.com thecryptickler@reddthat.com
Joined: 2026-10-25
#94 · Quote Reply

People are complicated. The same dummy who likes AI too much is also a very important developer and pretty big conservationist.

0
the_riviera_kid lemmy.world the_riviera_kid@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-03-10
#95 · Quote Reply

Is he only capable of saying the dumbest possible shit?

4
selokichtli lemmy.ml selokichtli@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2021-03-20
#96 · Quote Reply

The idea of hating AI is weird because they don't give a fuck and can have it their way with an "oopsie". Now we have their social warriors.

3
steelplatedmech piefed.ca steelplatedmech@piefed.ca
Joined: 2026-07-22
#97 · (edited) Quote Reply

Most people that go into making games don't go into it for profit. Do you think my friend went to make a Halo game because it was to make money or because it was fun to have a lan party?

I'm talking about you bringing up Uber as a positive example of a way to run a business. I don't think you know what you are talking about if you are using Uber to defend your position. Because Uber is one of the worst examples of a good company.

That you think it is some indie passion project is very questionable when it comes to the grasp of companies and how terrible they can be for customers and employees. Unsustainable mass corporations like Uber is what is leading to bunch of borrowed money flowing around and inflating the stock market while those at top get rich, get government subsidies, and firing their employees with all they care about being projected valuation.

3
the_riviera_kid lemmy.world the_riviera_kid@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-03-10
#98 · Quote Reply

In reply to an earlier post

"Ask ai"

And you are accusing others of sounding like a dumbass?

0
egregiousRac piefed.social phailhaus@piefed.social
Joined: 2026-03-09
#99 · Quote Reply

It's too bad, I really like his early work. Jill of the Jungle, Epic Pinball, Jazz the Jackrabbit, Tyrian, all the Unreal Tournament games, Unreal Engine 1/2/3

Epic Pinball was made by the founder of Digital Extremes. He and the team he built there did a ton of Unreal through UT2003. UT2004 was the end of the partnership, with Epic handling the new design work and Digital Extremes being relegated to art, UI, and a few maps.

4
mojofrododojo lemmy.world mojofrododojo@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-25
#100 · (edited) Quote Reply

Fuck off with your slop, Sweeney.

Sweeney Slop, The Demented Dev of Epic

5
myyass lemmy.world myyass@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-09-02
#101 · Quote Reply

I'm talking about you bringing up Uber as a positive example of a way to run a business. I don't think you know what you are talking about if you are using Uber to defend your position. Because Uber is one of the worst examples of a good company. That you think it is some indie passion project is very questionable when it comes to the grasp of companies and how terrible they can be for customer...

I think that was misinterpreted. Uber is absolute trash of a company.

I know what it's like to be a contractor. All work and none of the benefits.

I was trying to bring up the mess 343 was without saying it. Hundreds of "contractors" got laid off on release. There was a whole lot of tom-fuckery around that game. Microslop didn't want to give a few hundred people a crumb of the pie.

A lot of companies enjoy the dancing monkey in a top hat. So we're on the same page, sorry auto correct messes up what I write sometimes.

1
Post Reply Page 2 of 3   Goto page « First 1, 2, 3 Last »
Back to top