RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Sacrificing a child to power it all would just be giving it away
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
🍉 DrRedOctopus 🐙🍉 lemmy.world IAmNorRealTakeYourMeds@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-06-29
#52 · Quote Reply

someone mentioned that it's only a few pages long so I'm gonna try and read it as soon as i can get my hands on a copy.

https://shsdavisapes.pbworks.com/f/Omelas.pdf

it's available online. it's a good read, 30 minutes read 2 hours of digesting it afterwards

3
kieron115 startrek.website kieron115@startrek.website
Joined: 2024-02-14
#53 · Quote Reply

I love episodes with no neat resolution, like DS9's In The Pale Moonlight or TNG's Journey's End. But episodes like that are about the struggle with the unresolvable problem. We watch the show's respective captains grapple with and debate the problem for the whole episode. This episode is mostly a mystery about what the situation with the planet might be. It poses it's dilemma at the end and th...

Which feels more like moral abdication than a real ethical dilemma.

this is like the core of federation society haha. they wouldn't be able to live with themselves if they couldn't handwave things away with the prime directive.

3
kieron115 startrek.website kieron115@startrek.website
Joined: 2024-02-14
#54 · Quote Reply

https://shsdavisapes.pbworks.com/f/Omelas.pdf it's available online. it's a good read, 30 minutes read 2 hours of digesting it afterwards

Cool! Gonna go make some coffee, read this then watch the video someone linked further up. 👍

3
mathemachristian [he/him] lemmy.blahaj.zone mathemachristian@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2025-06-05
#55 · (edited) Quote Reply

he meant literally collapsing a society. as in, their foating cities would crash into a river of lava.

I simply wouldn't have made my floating cities above a river of lava depend on a childs suffering. Complete skill issue

4
kieron115 startrek.website kieron115@startrek.website
Joined: 2024-02-14
#56 · Quote Reply

I simply wouldn't have made my floating cities above a river of lava depend on a childs suffering. Complete skill issue

it was their ancient ancestors that built the city. entire planet lava. they were looking for alternatives but couldn't find any. you... understand that this is fiction, right?

1
mathemachristian [he/him] lemmy.blahaj.zone mathemachristian@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2025-06-05
#57 · Quote Reply

it was their ancient ancestors that built the city. entire planet lava. they were looking for alternatives but couldn't find any. you... understand that this is fiction, right?

yeah I was joking

3
kieron115 startrek.website kieron115@startrek.website
Joined: 2024-02-14
#58 · (edited) Quote Reply

yeah I was joking

oh okay i wasn't familiar with that one. reminds me of an IASIP scene lol.

2
Thebeardedsinglemalt lemmy.world Thebeardedsinglemalt@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-07-17
#59 · Quote Reply

There's only one specific event from disco that you need to know about to watch SNW anyway, and it only matters for the very first episode.

I tried watching the first 3 seasons but it was an absolute struggle. I had zero desire to do 4&5 but I was bored enough that I gave 5 a shot just out of curiosity to see where it goes. There were some interesting moments with potential, but it just kept getting more and more absurd with each episode...even when it got pretty self-aware

1
kieron115 startrek.website kieron115@startrek.website
Joined: 2024-02-14
#60 · (edited) Quote Reply

I tried watching the first 3 seasons but it was an absolute struggle. I had zero desire to do 4&5 but I was bored enough that I gave 5 a shot just out of curiosity to see where it goes. There were some interesting moments with potential, but it just kept getting more and more absurd with each episode...even when it got pretty self-aware

Yeah, I honestly noped out as soon as I saw the new klingons. I went back and watched the episode referenced in SNW E1 and that was about it.

1
mathemachristian [he/him] lemmy.blahaj.zone mathemachristian@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2025-06-05
#61 · Quote Reply

oh okay i wasn't familiar with that one. reminds me of an IASIP scene lol.

No harm done lol

2
Post Reply Page 2 of 2   Goto page « First 1, 2
Back to top