RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
arXiv bans academic authors for AI slop papers
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
David Gerard awful.systems dgerard@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
Quote

the hit AI dogs holler

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJg1wHzR1gc&list=UU9rJrMVgcXTfa8xuMnbhAEA - video
https://pivottoai.libsyn.com/20260215-arxiv-bans-academic-authors-for-ai-slop-papers - podcast

time: 8 min 39 sec

46   Original
scruiser awful.systems scruiser@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-08-29
#2 · Quote Reply

Every author named as writing a paper bears full responsibility for the paper.

This has the nice added bonus that it will likely catch PI's that put their name on their grad students paper without actually doing the mentoring they were supposed to. It will also catch professors that coast (or at least inflate their citation index) by getting their name on papers they barely contributed to.

I am quite convinced that, under these arxive guidelines, every single major PI in the field will be banned within a few years.

Catching a lot of PIs that have allowed and even encouraged slop submission is a good thing in my book.

12
antifuchs awful.systems antifuchs@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-22
#3 · Quote Reply

Publish and perish!

12
aio awful.systems aio@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-02-06
#4 · (edited) Quote Reply

It's not quite clear to me that

We rely on some standard LLM detectors to focus our attention on papers that need to be checked.

implies they are using LLMs themselves. The phrase "LLM detector" is a bit ambiguous and could mean "LLM being used as a detector" or just "classifier program designed to detect LLM output".

4
David Gerard Moderator dgerard@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
#5 · Quote Reply

It's not quite clear to me that We rely on some standard LLM detectors to focus our attention on papers that need to be checked. implies they are using LLMs themselves. The phrase "LLM detector" is a bit ambiguous and could mean "LLM being used as a detector" or just "classifier program designed to detect LLM output".

I don't know of any examples that aren't LLMs themselves.

4
aio awful.systems aio@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-02-06
#6 · Quote Reply

I don't know of any examples that aren't LLMs themselves.

Ah okay, I didn't realize that.

6
sc_griffith awful.systems sc_griffith@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-08-13
#7 · Quote Reply

fun fact: even vixra has had an anti ai paper policy for idk how long, at least ten months

https://bsky.app/profile/scgriffith.bsky.social/post/3lsek4cpnpk2n

7
blakestacey awful.systems blakestacey@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
#8 · Quote Reply

Corey S. Powell:

Imagine the staggering labor involved in sending around an email that says, "Nobody did anything dumb like using AI to generate the citations, right?" I mean, that could take seconds.

4
zogwarg awful.systems zogwarg@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#9 · Quote Reply

Corey S. Powell: Imagine the staggering labor involved in sending around an email that says, "Nobody did anything dumb like using AI to generate the citations, right?" I mean, that could take seconds.

Also what is even the meaning of adding citations if you never came across the source?

[I vaguely understand that there is a lot of window-dressing that comes with writing papers, but this is too perverse.]

5
David Gerard Moderator dgerard@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
#10 · Quote Reply

Also what is even the meaning of adding citations if you never came across the source? [I vaguely understand that there is a lot of window-dressing that comes with writing papers, but this is too perverse.]

people get told they have too few cites and need to add more. the result:

3
Post Reply
Back to top