The actor for Oh Father was on Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt as an aspiring reverend. Firecracker was on a The Following as a sycophantic worshipper who banged the cult leader.

I just thought it was funny. One actor is like okay, I'm reverend-coded, I can do the preacher voice, and the other was like I'm really good at playing a character with a lot of religious trauma who falls in love with a cult leader and follows him mindlessly until I'm killed.

Also Lamplighter was in The Following too. I watch too much TV. Life has been weird lately.

All of them killed it w/r/t acting, but I thought it was funny

One actor is like okay, I’m reverend-coded, I can do the preacher voice

He's a rapper...

Like, that bit in Kimmy Schmidt where he raps is a joke on another level because he's actually insanely talented.

You need an actor with a powerful voice, you get a talented actor that's an amazing rapper...

It was perfect casting and he killed it.

Edit:

Changed recommended song:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nm65PCbUMZI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nm65PCbUMZI

Ha he's so funny and talented, love it ty