RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
SUPERGIRL Review: No, It Doesn't Deserve All The Online Hate (And I Paid My Own Way To Tell You So)
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
TheImpressiveX lemmy.today TheImpressiveX@lemmy.today
Joined: 2025-06-03
Quote

30   Original
Dragomus lemmy.world Dragomus@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#2 · Quote Reply

Frankly, the movie is a fun ride, it has a few issues (which movie nowadays doesn't?) but it nowhere near deserves the hate campaign against it.

17
MimicJar Moderator MimicJar@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-05
#3 · Quote Reply

A whole lot of this hate feels like people piling on to pile on, hopping on the bandwagon to be part of the in-crowd, with no personal experience to actually draw from.

That's basically "The Internet" in a nutshell. Chuds on Twitter or wherever want to hate something and for whatever reason the rest of the Internet follows along. Twitter is a place of hate, nothing good comes from there. It's not a real place. Fuck em.

And I'm picking on Twitter, but fuck the whole lot of em. And I don't exclude Lemmy from this. I've jumped into threads on previous media that is just terrible dishonest mindless chatter. But this isn't new. Rage sells. But it's not real. It's not genuine. It isn't worth engaging with.


I've seen the film. I've read this article. I don't agree with it 100%, but it's pretty fair. Supergirl is a mostly mid film, leaning towards good. Somewhere between a 6/10 and a 7/10.

In a world of the MCU during its prime, when we got three films a year, it's Thor: The Dark World. Remember that film? And I don't mean the part that shows up during Endgame. But no, you don't remember it. But you might remember a few cool moments from it. Whatever we've got plenty more to see. Except we don't at the moment.

This is the follow up to Superman. This film needed to be a big hit. We're getting one film a year. (Plus some TV shows. Also Clayface but that's tonally a whole different beast.) So when this misses, it's going to miss big.


If you're excited for Supergirl, if you're seeing it this opening weekend, you'll find things to enjoy, I know I did. If you're on the fence, watch Supergirl when it hits streaming. You'll see the problems, but you'll still have some good moments to enjoy.

25
harrys_balzac lemmy.dbzer0.com harrys_balzac@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-03-21
#4 · Quote Reply

Frankly, the movie is a fun ride, it has a few issues (which movie nowadays doesn't?) but it nowhere near deserves the hate campaign against it.

I saw it yesterday and I really enjoyed it. Like you said, there some issues but none were big enough to ruin the movie.

I decided a few years ago to just ignore most of the online discourse around movies.

11
man_wtfhappenedtoyou lemmy.world man_wtfhappenedtoyou@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-10-27
#5 · Quote Reply

Frankly, the movie is a fun ride, it has a few issues (which movie nowadays doesn't?) but it nowhere near deserves the hate campaign against it.

I really have a hard time hating any movie I watch these days. And I recently watched Primate. It's just a fucking movie what are people expecting?

4
dontbelievethis sh.itjust.works dontbelievethis@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-07
#6 · Quote Reply

I really have a hard time hating any movie I watch these days. And I recently watched Primate. It's just a fucking movie what are people expecting?

What do you mean with "its just a movie?"

0
man_wtfhappenedtoyou lemmy.world man_wtfhappenedtoyou@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-10-27
#7 · Quote Reply

What do you mean with "its just a movie?"

I mean that it's a piece of media meant to occupy and entertain us to pass the time. If it's bad or good, who cares? It (and you) achieved your goal by passing the time, so in the end it doesn't much matter if it's good or bad. IMO this is especially true for superhero movies (aka capeslop), so it's especially dumb to get upset if you didn't enjoy it. People being snobby about superhero movies is some of the stupidest shit I can imagine. But hey, I guess if that's how people wanna spend their time I shouldn't let it bother me.

3
dontbelievethis sh.itjust.works dontbelievethis@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-07
#8 · Quote Reply

I mean that it's a piece of media meant to occupy and entertain us to pass the time. If it's bad or good, who cares? It (and you) achieved your goal by passing the time, so in the end it doesn't much matter if it's good or bad. IMO this is especially true for superhero movies (aka capeslop), so it's especially dumb to get upset if you didn't enjoy it. People being snobby about superhero movies ...

Okay but are you talking about superhero movies, this movie in particular or the concept of movies in general?

0
man_wtfhappenedtoyou lemmy.world man_wtfhappenedtoyou@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-10-27
#9 · Quote Reply

Okay but are you talking about superhero movies, this movie in particular or the concept of movies in general?

Movies in general mostly, excluding documentaries I suppose.

3
TachyonTele piefed.social TachyonTele@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-03
Banned
#10 · Quote Reply

I'm going to check out of regardless of reviews when it's streamed. It'll be a guilty pleasure cuz i love Supergirl outfits.

2
dontbelievethis sh.itjust.works dontbelievethis@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-07
#11 · Quote Reply

Movies in general mostly, excluding documentaries I suppose.

Hmm, okay.

-1
Post Reply
Back to top