• I made a Piefed* account, but I can't see the comments and posts from my Lemmy account. Or vice versa. What's up with that? Is there a "wall" between these communities?
• Is there a way to transfer posts etc from one account to another?

just curious.. what is pieface?

This thing: https://join.piefed.social/

1. I assume you mean Piefed.
2. Are you talking about your @Zarobi@quokk.au PyLova account?
3. Lemmy -> Piefed/PyLova works by ActivityPub. Piefed & PyLova largely follow the same “threadiverse” conventions as Lemmy, because they are clones of Lemmy.
4. I don’t know why you can’t see comments or posts from your Lemmy account. It may be for one of a few reasons. The instances may not be federated with each other, or the Piefed/PyLove instance may be newer than the comments & posts you’re looking for, so it doesn’t have a copy of them.

into which lemmy.world community did you post from piefed.social?

Oh yes sorry, I have dyslexia and I read it as pieface LOL how embarrassing

Yeah my accounts are:

• @Zarobi@aussie.zone (original account)
• @Zarobi@quokk.au (this account)

It seems like these instances maybe just don't talk to each other?

Just notifying that I answered in the other comment on this post (didn't want to double up the same info)

is it this post in technology (bottom)?

https://moist.catsweat.com/u/@Zarobi@quokk.au

Yes I can't see that from my Lemmy account, nor this post

i dont even use lemmy and i can see it, so, its clearly federating.

It appears that they do talk to each other:

• https://aussie.zone/instances
• https://quokk.au/instances?filters=federated&search=aussie.zone

 
This works: https://aussie.zone/u/Zarobi@quokk.au
but this doesn’t, and I don’t know why: https://quokk.au/u/Zarobi@aussie.zone

I don’t know why that doesn’t work when this does: https://quokk.au/u/davel@lemmy.ml
Perhaps it’s because none of your Zarobi@aussie.zone comments or posts have ever federated to quokk.au, so quokk.au isn’t aware of user Zarobi@aussie.zone’s existence yet. You could try subscribing to or commenting in a quokk.au community; maybe that would “prime the pump.”

Strange…

Yeah it's extremely weird… but I'm getting the feeling that these "instances" are kind of their own servers that are "friends"and subscribed with other servers? So maybe one of them refreshes more often than the other, or some friendships are one-way… That's just how I'm interpreting it based on all the info you gave me anyway

ActivityPub federation is very complicated, and I don’t have a full understanding of it myself. I’ve never come across a situation like this one before, where a user on one instance appears to not exist at all from the viewpoint of another instance that’s federated with it.

I do know that, compared to Lemmy, Piefed is buggy, and PyLova, as a soft fork of Piefed, presumably is buggy as well. You might try asking in a Piefed/PyLova support community. Maybe they’ve encountered this before.

They don't refresh at all, posts and comments get delivered to subscribed instances when they are created. Likely no one from your Piefed instance has been subscribing to the communities you posted to with your lemmy account at that time.

not all systems directly federate with each other... i seem to recall some bad blood between lemmy.world and lemmy.ml.. so posts made on one might not make it to the other regardless of your home server. no idea if thats still the case

its where the community is hosted that really matters, in the case of that last post 'Technology @ lemmy.world'

so any servers that purposefully block lemmy.world would not receive the post

That's very interesting, and probably explains the issue I've been having. Thanks!

Yeah it seems very complicated. I think I'll stick to my Lemmy account for now, it has all my post history and stuff as well. I might retry Piefed again after a while to see if it works better, my account will be waiting for me. Thanks for the help!

I've reached out to one of the admins from your server OP, in case there's a technical issue. In a pinch, you should always feel free to message your server admin if you think there's an issue!

Often servers will have "Meta" communities, designated as only for communications inside your local server.. These are great places to find help like this from folks who may have more understanding.

Good idea. I checked the "meta" community and it seems like a semi-known issue for about a month, specifically affecting these two communities. At least I'm not going nuts!

https://aussie.zone/post/34600112