RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Do you toss food once the date on the label has passed? Experts say that's often a waste
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
activistPnk slrpnk.net activistPnk@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2023-07-30
(edited) Quote

(cross-post of a thread in !food@slrpnk.net originally posted by someone else)

30   Original
solo slrpnk.net solo@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-05-18
#2 · (edited) Quote Reply

I don't remember who told me this "system" to check if food went bad, but it's a great one imo

  1. If it looks good, smell it
  2. If it smells good, taste it
  3. If it tastes good, eat it
22
activistPnk slrpnk.net activistPnk@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2023-07-30
#3 · (edited) Quote Reply

I don't remember who told me this "system" to check if food went bad, but it's a great one imo If it looks good, smell it If it smells good, taste it If it tastes good, eat it

I would add: if it tastes off, spit it out, as tasting does not imply swallowing.

Worth noting as well that the taste test can kill you when dealing with some very toxic variaties of wild mushrooms -- even if you spit it out.

8
Krusty quokk.au Krusty@quokk.au
Joined: 2026-05-03
#4 · Quote Reply

I don't remember who told me this "system" to check if food went bad, but it's a great one imo If it looks good, smell it If it smells good, taste it If it tastes good, eat it

Yea, good advice. But also good to remember you can't smell or taste salmonella, e coli, listeria, botulism, etc...

14
Cris_Citrus (he/him <3) piefed.zip Cris_Citrus@piefed.zip
Joined: 2026-02-26
#5 · Quote Reply

I would add: if it tastes off, spit it out, as tasting does not imply swallowing. Worth noting as well that the taste test can kill you when dealing with some very toxic variaties of wild mushrooms -- even if you spit it out.

Yeah, those rules don't feel meant for foraging, just for assessing spoilage

8
Cris_Citrus (he/him <3) piefed.zip Cris_Citrus@piefed.zip
Joined: 2026-02-26
#6 · Quote Reply

Yea, good advice. But also good to remember you can't smell or taste salmonella, e coli, listeria, botulism, etc...

That is a good reminder, thank you

2
solo slrpnk.net solo@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-05-18
#7 · Quote Reply

Yea, good advice. But also good to remember you can't smell or taste salmonella, e coli, listeria, botulism, etc...

Of course this approach has its limits. I thought it was clear when I said that this method is to "check if food went bad".

If something like meat has not been cooked, or a dairy product has not been properly pasteurised, or there where unsanitary food production conditions, or not canned properly etc, this method does not apply.

It is definately not a way to check if something is eadible in general. And if you are pregnant or have special diatery needs, you know the specifics of your situation.

6
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#8 · Quote Reply

"Expiration" dates are pure marketing, 100%. They only exist to pressure stores to restock asap for more profit to the sellers' shareholders, nothing more. 🤌🏼

1
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#9 · Quote Reply

I don't remember who told me this "system" to check if food went bad, but it's a great one imo If it looks good, smell it If it smells good, taste it If it tastes good, eat it

They never met a wild mushroom, I assume.

1
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#10 · (edited) Quote Reply

Of course this approach has its limits. I thought it was clear when I said that this method is to "check if food went bad". If something like meat has not been cooked, or a dairy product has not been properly pasteurised, or there where unsanitary food production conditions, or not canned properly etc, this method does not apply. It is definately not a way to check if something is eadible in ge...

AFAIK, you can't visually assess whether something's been "properly" pasteurized or canned, and plenty of traditional dishes use un/semi-cooked meats.

The saying smacks of <90s (if not <50s) in its deceptive simplicity, and assumption that the listener is smart enough to suss out the rare moments it's applicable.

(aside: definitely*, edible*)

1
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#11 · Quote Reply

Yeah, those rules don't feel meant for foraging, just for assessing spoilage

So, they're universal "rules" like the timeless "i before e" one, right?

0
RaphaelSchmitz feddit.org RaphaelSchmitz@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-04-28
#12 · Quote Reply

I don't remember who told me this "system" to check if food went bad, but it's a great one imo If it looks good, smell it If it smells good, taste it If it tastes good, eat it

Gotta be careful with cooked rice because it goes deadly in a way that's unnoticable

3
solo slrpnk.net solo@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-05-18
#13 · Quote Reply

Gotta be careful with cooked rice because it goes deadly in a way that's unnoticable

I suppose, yes and no. In a way the tricky thing is to know what to look for: to be able to recognize that a slimy texture is a sign that it has gone bad.

Here are some more medically reviewd tips from healthline:

Does Rice Go Bad? Shelf Life, Expiration Date, and Safe Storage

4
minorkeys sh.itjust.works minorkeys@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-04-22
#14 · Quote Reply

"Expiration" dates are pure marketing, 100%. They only exist to pressure stores to restock asap for more profit to the sellers' shareholders, nothing more. 🤌🏼

They are legal requirements afaik.

3
swelter_spark reddthat.com swelter_spark@reddthat.com
Joined: 2025-03-06
#15 · Quote Reply

I wish I could get my bf to believe this.

5
db_null lemmy.dbzer0.com db_null@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-02-16
#16 · (edited) Quote Reply

I wish I could get my bf to believe this.

Share some facts and official advise, that should convince any reasonable person. If your region doesn't differentiate between 'use by' and 'best by' then the website lists the foods to be eztra cautious with (e.g. meat, fish, dairy)

https://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/safe2eat/food-date-labelling

4
Gsus4 mander.xyz Gsus4@mander.xyz
Joined: 2023-08-25
#17 · (edited) Quote Reply

yogurt, cereal, UHT milk, pasta, rice, canned stuff...dried stuff...none of them expire. I once lost a yogurt (sealed) on a desktop behind some paperwork (very much not refrigerated, not advised) and once I found it a few months later...it was still good edible :D

4
BarneyPiccolo lemmy.today BarneyPiccolo@lemmy.today
Joined: 2025-06-30
#18 · (edited) Quote Reply

My wife goes strictly by the date, even before sometimes. Doesn't matter what it looks, smells, or tastes like, if it's at the date, it gets tossed.

Some dates she makes up, like deli meat. She gives it 3 days, and it's gone, which isy biggest irritation. Nothing worse than looking forward to a sandwich, only to find out that it all got tossed.

It's been over 30 years, I've moved on from that argument. I just try to find the stuff that's getting close, and use it up.

4
BarneyPiccolo lemmy.today BarneyPiccolo@lemmy.today
Joined: 2025-06-30
#19 · Quote Reply

They never met a wild mushroom, I assume.

Yesterday, I passed a deer chowing down on mushroom fairy ring. Not really relevant, but your mention of mushrooms reminded me.

6
activistPnk slrpnk.net activistPnk@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2023-07-30
#20 · (edited) Quote Reply

My wife goes strictly by the date, even before sometimes. Doesn't matter what it looks, smells, or tastes like, if it's at the date, it gets tossed. Some dates she makes up, like deli meat. She gives it 3 days, and it's gone, which isy biggest irritation. Nothing worse than looking forward to a sandwich, only to find out that it all got tossed. It's been over 30 years, I've moved on from that a...

Guess I’d try getting a separate mini-fridge, with a lock. When something is ~2 days before triggering the chronic waste manager, move it to the locked fridge.

2
activistPnk slrpnk.net activistPnk@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2023-07-30
#21 · (edited) Quote Reply

Gotta be careful with cooked rice because it goes deadly in a way that's unnoticable

I’ve seen refrigerated cooked rice turn pink and slimey in spots. I trash the dodgy looking stuff and fry the rest. Is that a bad idea? I got away with it twice so far. Now I leave the lid loose so some of the moisture can escape.

(edit) after reading the link posted by 'solo', I guess i should freeze rice if I don’t use it after a couple days.

2
swelter_spark reddthat.com swelter_spark@reddthat.com
Joined: 2025-03-06
#22 · Quote Reply

Share some facts and official advise, that should convince any reasonable person. If your region doesn't differentiate between 'use by' and 'best by' then the website lists the foods to be eztra cautious with (e.g. meat, fish, dairy) https://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/safe2eat/food-date-labelling

He has a lot of anxiety about things he mentally relates to poverty. When I'm making food for us, I use my own judgment, though. :p

2
jol discuss.tchncs.de jol@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-10-25
#23 · Quote Reply

My wife goes strictly by the date, even before sometimes. Doesn't matter what it looks, smells, or tastes like, if it's at the date, it gets tossed. Some dates she makes up, like deli meat. She gives it 3 days, and it's gone, which isy biggest irritation. Nothing worse than looking forward to a sandwich, only to find out that it all got tossed. It's been over 30 years, I've moved on from that a...

Clearly she's abusive and you need to dump her ASAP.

Oh wait this isn't r*eddit. Never mind, good job on your 30 years.

2
pseudo slrpnk.net pseudo@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-03-06
#24 · Quote Reply

Yesterday, I passed a deer chowing down on mushroom fairy ring. Not really relevant, but your mention of mushrooms reminded me.

Thank you for sharing this.

2
RaphaelSchmitz feddit.org RaphaelSchmitz@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-04-28
#25 · Quote Reply

I’ve seen refrigerated cooked rice turn pink and slimey in spots. I trash the dodgy looking stuff and fry the rest. Is that a bad idea? I got away with it twice so far. Now I leave the lid loose so some of the moisture can escape. (edit) after reading the link posted by 'solo', I guess i should freeze rice if I don’t use it after a couple days.

I gotta admit I'm a bit confused because none of the articles posted here - articles made specifically to talk about if rice is safe - seem to be aware of fried rice syndrome? The thing that is such a thing that it got an own name?

The danger about fried rice syndrome is that it is unnoticeable. Meat goes bad, it stinks or gets white dots, etc. Fried rice syndrome, it doesn't appear different at all and you can just straight up die from it. Restaurants only make rice fresh because of this danger.

But restaurants are extra careful, of course. At home, if you make sure to cool your rice quickly it's ok. Which also means, don't put one huge bowl of warm rice I to your fridge, because it will stay warm enough for the bacteria in the middle.

It's also one if those things that doesn't happen often, so there's a chance you go through your whole life without this ever being a problem, but I don't wanna die from bowl of rice.

2
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#26 · Quote Reply

Yesterday, I passed a deer chowing down on mushroom fairy ring. Not really relevant, but your mention of mushrooms reminded me.

Similarly, I was camping waaay out some years back, and discovered during pack-out that one of my magic chocolate truffles was missing. I found it by the firewood cache, but nearly half eaten, and still being gripped in one of the dead mouse's forepaws. 🤷🏼‍♂️ Ya live & learn, or ya don't, I guess. That little guy rejoined the cosmos in Technicolor, though! 🤗

2
sinza piefed.social sinza@piefed.social
Joined: 2026-09-15
#27 · Quote Reply

Definitely an extreme example, but within the last week I had cottage cheese that had a date on the label of 2024. It was kept in a cold part of the fridge the whole time and was not opened until I had it.

Not only was it still good, it was outright the best-tasting cottage cheese I've had.

2
Post Reply
Back to top