Idk about better but I need a LOTR trilogy like this.

All of them.

Eyes Wide Shut

That would be interesting. Because he'd play it completely straight. You'd be expecting the joke, but, nope, it's just that Weird Al is Aragorn.

Obviously Nicole Kidman’s role.

If they remake Spy Hard like they did with Naked Gun, let him do the theme song and the lead role.

UHF.

That movie would be unwatchable with anyone else

Right? You'd be better off asking which movies wouldn't be better? That's a tricky question.

highlander 2. There's no way it could be worse.

The Hobbit trilogy

Melania

Magic Mike

UHF is the only movie that wouldn't be better with Weird Al as the lead, because it's already there.

Lot of interesting answers here, but for me, the obvious choice is "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory"

“I can’t carry it for you, but I can carry you!”

scene fucking EXPLODES into a high tempo musical number

Muppet Treasure Island, but only if he played it straight like he was actually Kermit

Joker (2019)

Machete

No, he plays the masks.

Obviously the, ahem, climax is an orgy of Weird Als.

Holy hell I would watch the hell out of that. Bonus points if they redo the whole thing scene by scene.

Fight Club as the narrator. Easy to imagine him snuggling Bob's giant tits.

Yes.

Not a knock on Tom Hulce, but Amadeus

American Psycho

Edit: I had almost forgotten about this: https://youtu.be/Fk15H6PjBis

Die Hard would be fun

Eraserhead.

Backdoor Sluts 9

Holy shit. I never knew I needed this until now.

Obviously the, ahem, climax is an orgy of Weird Als.

Being John Malkovich.

muppet treasure island but weird al is the only human

are we talking 80s dorky al or today's "can pull off serious" al?

if it's the former, death wish 3.

if it's the latter, mandy.

I want a movie based on the craziest shit Al has done in his life but told in a BJM parody called Being Al Yankovic.

On their second channel, the Epic Rap Battles guys post reaction videos to suggested matchups. One of their dream matchups is Willy Wonka vs Pablo Escobar with Weird Al playing Wonka but they're afraid he'd say no because of the gratuitous drug references that would be involved.

This is Spinal Tap Weird Al

Rambo, Duh.

But then replace EVERY actor with Weird Al.

Bocchi the Rock

I would love to see him as a John Wick style character.

Alternatively he and Jack Black could bring back the Blues Brothers

Titanic with Al as Rose.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

god damn! 🤣

Annie, the musical.

The Weird Al Movie. Haha jk Dan Radcliffe did a great job.

Star Trek The Motion Picture, but with Weird Al as V’Ger.

Mandy and Melania are my top pics so far

Alternatively he and Jack Black could bring back the Blues Brothers

You have my full attention.

We have a quorum. Calling warner brothers

Justice League, but with Weird Al as Wonder Woman.