RetroFed Forums
Your home away from modern life.
Mod removed innocous post from Dadjokes because "kids don't understand gay marriage"
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
idiomaddict lemmy.world idiomaddict@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-16
#152 · (edited) Quote Reply

but ideally I’m holding out for a German language instance that accepts criticism of Israel (I can dream) Def. create the community here then. Quokk.au was forked for anti-genocide & anti-apartheid praxis. We were there when .world was defending Zionism. When they merged into Zion camp, many users emigrated. time zones, because I get stressed out when I feel like I should have responded mor...

Yeah, I strongly disagree with .world’s (and feddit.org’s) views on Zionism, but I just compartmentalize my usage based on my account instance. I’m also personally against the death penalty, which seems to make me pretty unremarkable for most .world mods, even though I’m definitely not against hoping some people die (it’s sadly actually too long a list to make here, but it includes multiple whole professions).

not in piefed, .ml, and FHF😅. They have paid moderation.

Huh, TIL. Glück im Unglück, I’m too poor to have ever sent them or sadly you guys money.

1
alapakala quokk.au alapakala@quokk.au
Joined: 2026-03-16
#153 · Quote Reply

Yeah, I strongly disagree with .world’s (and feddit.org’s) views on Zionism, but I just compartmentalize my usage based on my account instance. I’m also personally against the death penalty, which seems to make me pretty unremarkable for most .world mods, even though I’m definitely not against hoping some people die (it’s sadly actually too long a list to make here, but it includes multiple who...

against the death penalty

welcome home🥲

I’m too poor to have ever sent them or sadly you guys money

😭🤝🫂

1
bitjunkie lemmy.world bitjunkie@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-06-19
#154 · Quote Reply

A reasonable reason to remove it was because it's not a dad joke. A funny joke, but not a dad joke

While I somewhat agree, that wasn't the reason given.

4
SCmSTR lemmy.blahaj.zone SCmSTR@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2023-07-24
#155 · (edited) Quote Reply

Mod posted a response: https://lemmy.world/post/52564578 I have recently received some feedback about including sexuality as a topic for dad jokes. Although it was not the most constructive of feedback, some points were made. Sex as a topic is not the same as sexuality, and I apologize for not making that distinction clearer. I was basing my moderating on what was being reported and sex being a...

This person believes in abstinence

Also, did they unban the post? Or is this just damage control?

8
njm1314 lemmy.world njm1314@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-21
#156 · Quote Reply

If your 5-year-old can't understand someone being gay then you're a shit parent.

21
Nangijala feddit.dk Nangijala@feddit.dk
Joined: 2025-02-28
#157 · Quote Reply

. If I may pretend for a second, that was a particularly nitpicky mod, I would have made a comment mentioning this rule and started a discussion with you and the other users to find out whether or not the joke was too clever for a five year old or if other people in the comments could attest to their five year olds being able to get the joke or not. That way it becomes a productive community di...

Oh, I'm glad to hear that everything was solved peacefully! 🤗

Speaking of which, do you know if mods and/or admins have the ability to move posts to other communities?

As far as I know, I don't think they do. I am a mod in a couple of small communities and it doesn't seem like I have the power to move posts around.

All we can do as either mods or regular users is try and help and guide one another so that we make posts in the appropriate communities moving forward and not start deleting posts left and right. That's at least how I prefer to do things. I know rules and temperments are very different from place to place and I find that way too many communities and mods are too trigger happy over too little which creates very negative, short fused atmospheres whwre everybody becomes a rapid dog who assumes ill intent everytime and all the time. It is a shame. It ruins too many communities and I prefer that situations like the one you were just in, will be solved as peacefully as possible so that everybody can remain friendly and trusting. It's a much healthier environment <3

3
glimse lemmy.world glimse@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-07
#158 · Quote Reply

While I somewhat agree, that wasn't the reason given.

Right, I was trying to imply that their reason was bad

1
rumba lemmy.zip rumba@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2024-09-24
#159 · Quote Reply

Mod posted a response: https://lemmy.world/post/52564578 I have recently received some feedback about including sexuality as a topic for dad jokes. Although it was not the most constructive of feedback, some points were made. Sex as a topic is not the same as sexuality, and I apologize for not making that distinction clearer. I was basing my moderating on what was being reported and sex being a...

That is a fantastic response. Bravo. Stuff like that is what keeps us from becoming another Reddit shit hole.

6
Buddahriffic lemmy.world Buddahriffic@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-30
#160 · Quote Reply

If your 5-year-old can't understand someone being gay then you're a shit parent.

It really depends on the kid. Some 5 year olds just don't give a fuck about any of that relationship shit and IMO it's not so important that they need to be sat down and told all about all the attraction options. I don't just mean the alternate ones but also man and woman.

If they ask questions or show interest in the topic, I think they should be answered honestly, but the only essential information at that age IMO is about personal space, not touching people who don't want to be touched (at all if that's their desire but especially in the private areas), understanding that they are the ones in charge of deciding if someone else touching them is ok (though at that age, it would be more of a "you don't have you let anyone see or touch there unless it's an emergency like it got hurt"), and that anyone asking them to keep secrets from their parents without it involving presents or a happy surprise isn't their friend.

That said, there's nothing wrong with this joke. Either it will go over the kid's head and they ignore it or it will make them curious and prompt those questions. If you respond to those questions with deflections and/or lies, then I'd agree with the shit parent accusation. Same thing applies to not wanting certain topics visible at all for fear that kids might ask questions about them. That cowardice isn't doing their kids any favours.

You can be honest about what sex is without giving the necessary details for them to act it out.

-4
JcbAzPx lemmy.world JcbAzPx@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-06
#161 · Quote Reply

Someone needs to tell that mod that dad jokes aren't for the kids.

19
DudleyMason lemmy.ml DudleyMason@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2026-03-19
#162 · Quote Reply

so a teenager's dad cannot crack dad jokes anymore?

Nah, the sole mod for that comm is just a weirdo prude.

0
zarathustrad lemmy.world zarathustrad@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-06-04
#163 · Quote Reply

Equating gay/bi people with sex and therefore inappropriate for children is a tactic of bigotry. The same argument was used to say that it's wrong for Mr. Ratburn to get married on Arthur, despite the episode being completely innocuous, or for any of the lgbtq characters in Steven Universe to exist. It's literally an argument to exclude queer people from society.

The concept of "Dad" is too complex for children, and implies (at its core) the act of sex.

We should ban the concept of "Dad" from all forms that could be seen by children.

5
ayyy sh.itjust.works ayyy@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2024-06-20
#164 · Quote Reply

Ok this mod has gone absolutely mask-off about being a homophobic bigot despite their two-faced attempt at mollifying the backlash. Shame on you @loopy@lemmy.world

0
Axolotl.cpp lemmy.dbzer0.com Axolotl_cpp@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-10-01
#165 · (edited) Quote Reply

Ignoring that the avarage age of lemmy could be 25 up to 35 years

but sexuality not until closer to puberty

I'd say that a kid would understand sexuality better "look, they just love eachothers" vs "they are male but with a female body" or sum

10
Viking_Hippie lemmy.dbzer0.com Viking_Hippie@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-12-04
#166 · Quote Reply

Ignoring that the avarage age of lemmy could be 25 up to 35 years but sexuality not until closer to puberty I'd say that a kid would understand sexuality better "look, they just love eachothers" vs "they are male but with a female body" or sum

Ignoring that the avarage age of lemmy could be 25 up to 35 years

I think it's actually much higher.

This is admittedly purely anecdotal and your mileage may thus vary, but in my experience as an elder millennial, most people here are around my age or older 🤷🏻

5
Axolotl.cpp lemmy.dbzer0.com Axolotl_cpp@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-10-01
#167 · Quote Reply

Ignoring that the avarage age of lemmy could be 25 up to 35 years I think it's actually much higher. This is admittedly purely anecdotal and your mileage may thus vary, but in my experience as an elder millennial, most people here are around my age or older 🤷🏻

Yeah but not all people, it's an avarage so it will naturally be lower

2
Viking_Hippie lemmy.dbzer0.com Viking_Hippie@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-12-04
#168 · Quote Reply

Yeah but not all people, it's an avarage so it will naturally be lower

If most people here are my age or older, it follows that the average must be younger? 🤔

2
Fmstrat lemmy.world Fmstrat@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-04-27
#169 · Quote Reply

Scrolling through the community quickly, there were like 3 jokes mentioning a husband's wife, one mentioning a car's manual transmission stalling, and one that's over a week old that includes the word "ass' which is directly breaking the no-profanity rule, yet somehow the concept of a gay couple is too confusing for a 6 year old? Oh and also a joke about "Cherenkov radiation" which I am 1000% c...

Mods have responded in other threads. Good response and taking a look at the rules.

2
Axolotl.cpp lemmy.dbzer0.com Axolotl_cpp@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-10-01
#170 · (edited) Quote Reply

If most people here are my age or older, it follows that the average must be younger? 🤔

A smaller or a too big number will throw off the avarage, that's also why using the avarage to see how much a country population earn is bad since billionare and millionare people exist

1
Herbal Gamer sh.itjust.works HerbalGamer@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-10-30
#171 · Quote Reply

It really depends on the kid. Some 5 year olds just don't give a fuck about any of that relationship shit and IMO it's not so important that they need to be sat down and told all about all the attraction options. I don't just mean the alternate ones but also man and woman. If they ask questions or show interest in the topic, I think they should be answered honestly, but the only essential infor...

I don’t just mean the alternate ones but also man and woman.

oh yeah I have an unmarried aunt and uncle and it took me way longer than I'd like to admit to realise they were a couple.

3
Viking_Hippie lemmy.dbzer0.com Viking_Hippie@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-12-04
#172 · Quote Reply

A smaller or a too big number will throw off the avarage, that's also why using the avarage to see how much a country population earn is bad since billionare and millionare people exist

So what you're saying is that the median age here is close to my estimate, but there's a handful of precocious toddlers throwing off the average? 😄

1
Axolotl.cpp lemmy.dbzer0.com Axolotl_cpp@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-10-01
#173 · Quote Reply

So what you're saying is that the median age here is close to my estimate, but there's a handful of precocious toddlers throwing off the average? 😄

Yep

2
AnarchistArtificer lemmy.world AnarchistArtificer@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-13
#174 · Quote Reply

I've known what lesbians were for as long as I can remember, because I have an auntie who was in a civil partnership with another woman. Apparently when it was explained to me in basic terms (after I had asked what a lesbian was, as I'd overheard it), I was just like "oh, okay." and went back to playing. Kids are better at understanding this stuff than we give them credit for

3
SourDragon lemmy.world SourDragon@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-07-21
#175 · Quote Reply

I don't see it as a "kids don't understand gay people", and I think the mod was justified. I'm grateful this forum has the respect to give me the courage to share my feelings. Just kidding! Downvote away.

The original post was put back up because the mod who removed realised they were in the wrong

1
Post Reply Page 4 of 4   Goto page « First 1, 2, 3, 4
Back to top