| Post Reply | RetroFed Forum Forum Index » Doctor Who Social Club |
| Author | Message | ||
|---|---|---|---|
SiliconAvatar
startrek.website
SiliconAvatar@startrek.websiteJoined: 2026-06-11 |
More excerpts from RTD's memoir revealed:
|
||
| 11 Original | |||
ValueSubtracted
Moderator
ValueSubtracted@startrek.websiteJoined: 2023-06-11 |
Honestly sounds pretty great.
This one, too.
This would probably be fine? Not too exciting to read about, but then I've never seen "Rocks." I wonder if these scripts will ever see the light of day in one format or another. |
||
| 4 | |||
SiliconAvatar
startrek.website
SiliconAvatar@startrek.websiteJoined: 2026-06-11 |
We had a brilliant story set during the Great Fire of London, written by the powerhouse team of Laurence Clark and Jack Thorne, and we should have had the budget to do it properly, with the flames and panic and everything. Honestly sounds pretty great. And we had a brutal horror story, written by the brilliant Lydia Adetunji, set on a NASA-type space station, all about trypophobia – look it up,...
They all sound interesting, I think. A Dalek four-parter, too, at least in theory. The maddening part is, this shows that Davies and Bad Wolf had season 3 planned out, far enough to commission scripts — without any season order from the BBC or its partner. I do hope these can be retooled for a future series, I'm always up for an abstract space horror (yes, even "Sleep no more"). And I've seen many fans wishing for Jack Thorne as show runner, so it would be interesting to see his take on the Doctor. What I get from the memoir excerpts so far is that Davies does a very rosy revision of the story, and dangling these could've-beens to distract from that. Elsewhere he's pretending "The reality war" didn't need a rewrite and extensive reshoots to accommodate Gatwa's exit — "oh, we knew Ncuti was leaving". Really? Because as of October 2024 Gatwa thought he was going to shoot s3 the following year. He said as much on the Graham Norton show. I'm not buying much of RTD's version to be honest. Not that it matters of course, there will be a new production soon enough. But the season that never materialised will probably haunt the fandom — perhaps the general viewership — for a while. |
||
| 2 | |||
ValueSubtracted
Moderator
ValueSubtracted@startrek.websiteJoined: 2023-06-11 |
They all sound interesting, I think. A Dalek four-parter, too, at least in theory. The maddening part is, this shows that Davies and Bad Wolf had season 3 planned out, far enough to commission scripts — without any season order from the BBC or its partner. I do hope these can be retooled for a future series, I'm always up for an abstract space horror (yes, even "Sleep no more"). And I've seen m...
We'll get there eventually in the retrospectives, but yeah, I think "Sleep No More" is fine. Not a home run, but fine.
He's a real bulllshitter, and seems too diplomatic to tell a gritty tell-all. But these excerpts seem true to be, even if they're incomplete. I do have questions about whether these writers were paid for their "fully written" scripts - I assume they must have been, which is odd. |
||
| 2 | |||
| Post Reply |
Back to top |