Link: https://www.thedrive.com/news/chinese-ev-brake-pedal-snaps-three-times-during-testing

The testers even bought a brand-new model just to make sure this was no coincidence—and it wasn't.

...

A brake pedal snapping during an emergency stop is just about one of the worst calamities that can happen on the road, and it appears a luxury EV in China carries that risk right now. Three Maextro V800 vans—built by JAC Group and tech giant Huawei—separately suffered three pedal fractures during 60-to-0-mph braking tests, prompting the manufacturer to begrudgingly commit to fix the component’s design and provide owners free replacements.

These tests made the rounds on Dongchedi, a car content platform that happens to be owned by ByteDance, which also runs TikTok. The first two failures happened to low-mileage vehicles, and their pedals snapped on their third and fourth runs. The third failure struck a brand new van purchased later, and its pedal collapsed on the second attempt.

Each failure required the testers to immediately engage the Park gear as a makeshift emergency brake, which does eventually stop the vehicle—though, as you can see in the footage, not quickly. The video below is in Chinese, but it’s not hard to get the gist of what’s going on. The driver presses hard, something audibly breaks, and the pedal falls all the way to the back of the footwell, dangling.

...

Archived

Interesting that in the headline it's a "Chinese EV" rather than any specific model. Imagine seeing the same headline but with "American truck."

Engaging the park gear at speed on an ICE wouldn’t do much, because the pawl would snap. Do they mean parking brake?

The automaker’s position is that these defects were discovered during “non-standard, extreme test conditions,”

yes that’s what emergency braking is. Non-standard use. It might happen twice in a vehicles lifetime or 200 times a day depending on whether the driver is a bus driver, but in any case it must not break.

Fearmongering to try and drive down demand for Chinese EVs...

If you are worried about this, get your local politicians to regulate vehicle safety, not ban one import source, or you'll just end up with plastic brake pedals from the western enshittification masters all the same, and you'll be paying more for the privilege.

Maybe. But if there were a headline with "American truck", then I don't think someone commented by asking to imagine a headline "Chinese EV". The whataboutism only works in one direction.

Presumably the primary demographic of thedrive.com is in the US and wouldn't have a lot of knowledge about specific chinese car models and brands, seeing as how we don't have access to any of them.

It seems pretty obvious that they would never even consider using "American truck" like that. It would be "2027 Ford F150" or whatever.

American EV gas pedal falls off.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/tesla-cybertruck-recall-accelerator-pedal-1.7178569

In a video made by a Chinese team in Chinese?

seems that way to me. apparently people in china are fearmongering to drive down demand for chinese imports or get them band.

I think part of it is its chinese testing for a chinese vehicle from a chinese sorce. At some point they are going to have to mention it.

Taiwan also has Chinese people who speak Chinese.

The video says a specific make and model. Not, "China EV".

Unless thedrive.com is a chinese outlet, too, I have no idea what kind of point you're trying to make.

Engaging the park gear at speed

I guess it's from the fact that "D" / "P" / "R" are on the selector, so "Park" gets promoted to honorary gear status these days.

Putting an EV into "Park" activates the (electrically actuated) parking brake. Which isn't really made to be activated when the vehicle is in motion, so it's anyone's guess whether it will burn out its tiny brake pads before you actually stop.

In any case, that brake pedal should be able to withstand as much force as a human can place on it. Plus a bit, because humans can be unexpectedly strong when they are stressed out. Ideally from a design perspective it would be able to travel until it reaches the floor and then be supported by the floor.

Maybe start by finding that headline

Not the video, the article and headline.

Ahh yes, classic china not knowing how to make a good gas padel, unlike america which as we all know did not have this issue very recently

The headline literally names the brand.

Okay, but that brand is Elon Musk, and nobody should buy anything even remotely owned by him.

This is what happens when you trust some random "news" outlet that nobody has heard of.

So does the article. Not the headline.

Wooosh

Yes, when it's an American company. That's the double standard they're pointing out

@Alvaro@lemmy.blahaj.zone

These tests made the rounds on Dongchedi, a car content platform that happens to be owned by ByteDance, which also runs TikTok.

These tests have been made by Chinese testers working for a platform owned by a Chinese company.

Nothing comes from the West. But even here the propaganda slop descends into whataboutism. I don't mean to offend anyone, but what is this if not brainwashed?

Yes, and most people don't read past the headline.