RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Former Valve writer says Gabe Newell has been pretty clear about Steam: "It's an MMO"
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
alessandro lemmy.ca alessandro@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-07-02
Quote

76   Original
Brave Little Hitachi Wand feddit.uk yakko@feddit.uk
Joined: 2025-01-08
#2 · Quote Reply

Arresting to have been using a thing so clearly designed to have gamelike features and never quite noticing it. I tend to credit myself as being fairly media literate and conscious about games, I guess either I'm wrong about that or they did an amazing job at it. I'll have to think carefully about that.

34
lime! feddit.nu lime@feddit.nu
Joined: 2024-08-21
#3 · Quote Reply

i mean yeah?

i've never really used that part, other than running a script every year to sell cards that accumulate by themselves for a little bit of credit. don't really seem like a big part of it.

then again i'm not a gambler. i guess people could get stuck in that sort of thing.

9
irate944 piefed.social irate944@piefed.social
Joined: 2026-01-29
#4 · Quote Reply

Arresting to have been using a thing so clearly designed to have gamelike features and never quite noticing it. I tend to credit myself as being fairly media literate and conscious about games, I guess either I'm wrong about that or they did an amazing job at it. I'll have to think carefully about that.

10-15 years ago, I knew a guy that bought games and traded cards just to level up his account. I remember asking him why he did it - since the levels are pretty much just cosmetic after the initial levels - and he straight up just said he liked to see the number go up

28
Brave Little Hitachi Wand feddit.uk yakko@feddit.uk
Joined: 2025-01-08
#5 · Quote Reply

10-15 years ago, I knew a guy that bought games and traded cards just to level up his account. I remember asking him why he did it - since the levels are pretty much just cosmetic after the initial levels - and he straight up just said he liked to see the number go up

Ahh jeez, fuck I hate it

13
pulsewidth lemmy.world pulsewidth@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-01-29
#6 · (edited) Quote Reply

Arresting to have been using a thing so clearly designed to have gamelike features and never quite noticing it. I tend to credit myself as being fairly media literate and conscious about games, I guess either I'm wrong about that or they did an amazing job at it. I'll have to think carefully about that.

It is in no way an MMO, so don't feel bad.

It's a community-focussed store, bordering on being a social media network.

The crap they talk about with "levelling-up" and decorating your profile have nothing to do with gamifying the experience - they're just a way to add more microtransactions for yacht money.

47
46_and_2 lemmy.world 46_and_2@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-04
#7 · Quote Reply

10-15 years ago, I knew a guy that bought games and traded cards just to level up his account. I remember asking him why he did it - since the levels are pretty much just cosmetic after the initial levels - and he straight up just said he liked to see the number go up

A friend of mine told me you get some additional discounts during Steam sales if you craft badges with cards. Never tried it or cared enough to do it, but if it's true that might be another motivation.

4
Elvith Ma'for feddit.org elvith@feddit.org
Joined: 2024-06-21
#8 · Quote Reply

10-15 years ago, I knew a guy that bought games and traded cards just to level up his account. I remember asking him why he did it - since the levels are pretty much just cosmetic after the initial levels - and he straight up just said he liked to see the number go up

Do those trading cards still have any value (a few cents are ok) and are people really buying those? I never noticed that you could sell them. I do nothing with them. And having a very small "discount" on my next game would probably be worth more for me than some NFT like things that collect the digital equivalent of dust in my account.

5
epicurean_toast lemmus.org epicurean_toast@lemmus.org
Joined: 2026-08-05
#9 · Quote Reply

10-15 years ago, I knew a guy that bought games and traded cards just to level up his account. I remember asking him why he did it - since the levels are pretty much just cosmetic after the initial levels - and he straight up just said he liked to see the number go up

There's a bevy of "idle" games that are all about that. One if the most popular is literally called Numbers Go Up Idle

3
uninvitedguest piefed.ca uninvitedguest@piefed.ca
Joined: 2025-06-07
#10 · Quote Reply

i mean yeah? i've never really used that part, other than running a script every year to sell cards that accumulate by themselves for a little bit of credit. don't really seem like a big part of it. then again i'm not a gambler. i guess people could get stuck in that sort of thing.

Pray tell, what script?

7
tempest lemmy.ca tempest@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-30
#11 · Quote Reply

It is in no way an MMO, so don't feel bad. It's a community-focussed store, bordering on being a social media network. The crap they talk about with "levelling-up" and decorating your profile have nothing to do with gamifying the experience - they're just a way to add more microtransactions for yacht money.

At least out of all the yacht money on the planet, his goes to science yachts as well.

In no way is he altruistic or he'd not be a billionaire, but he's farther from the evil than the rest of the public billionaires.

4
cannedtuna lemmy.world cannedtuna@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-21
#12 · Quote Reply

“You level up your account. You get things for playing games.“ Trading cards, profile page decorations, and the like are all tools for self-expression. "There's all of these elements that let you express who you are as a person as well as then MMO-ing the entire experience and leveling up," he says. "Then you have things that you can give to other people, and awards, and all of that."

So… like… all the least used features of the software? That’s what he’s saying people like best?

33
frank sopuli.xyz frank@sopuli.xyz
Joined: 2023-06-05
#13 · Quote Reply

Do those trading cards still have any value (a few cents are ok) and are people really buying those? I never noticed that you could sell them. I do nothing with them. And having a very small "discount" on my next game would probably be worth more for me than some NFT like things that collect the digital equivalent of dust in my account.

Yes, they do, a few cents. It's a pain to sell them, since you seemingly have to do it one at a time. But some of them are even like 1$/€ so those are worth it

4
lime! feddit.nu lime@feddit.nu
Joined: 2024-08-21
#14 · Quote Reply

Pray tell, what script?

it's one of those greasemonkey ones, i need to look it up every time because i always remove it after.

2
Elvith Ma'for feddit.org elvith@feddit.org
Joined: 2024-06-21
#15 · Quote Reply

Yes, they do, a few cents. It's a pain to sell them, since you seemingly have to do it one at a time. But some of them are even like 1$/€ so those are worth it

Just checked - I got over two hundred trading cards. On one hand, that's a pita to sell individually, on the other hand that's probably a free game in the next sale...

But I can do it over time and sell them bit by bit, no hurry...

1
Siegfried lemmy.world Siegfried@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#16 · Quote Reply

It is in no way an MMO, so don't feel bad. It's a community-focussed store, bordering on being a social media network. The crap they talk about with "levelling-up" and decorating your profile have nothing to do with gamifying the experience - they're just a way to add more microtransactions for yacht money.

It's a community-focussed rental shop, bordering on being a social media network.

2
supersquirrel lemmy.ca supersquirrel@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2026-08-07
#17 · (edited) Quote Reply

No it isn't.

It is not a game.

A game is a form of art, Steam exists to make Gabe money it is not a work of art and has no artistic relationship with its players and the fact that Gabe doesn't understand that as CEO of a gaming company is fucking embarassing.

I am tired of this lazy conflation of attaching superficial, lazy carrots on sticks to things and calling it "gamification" it is such an empty, cynical condescending way of looking at the world.

Why is everyone so condescending about games? No Gabe Steam is not an MMO because it isn't fun, there is no actual core experience other than numbers going up. Therefor it is NOT a game.

Now if you wanted to argue Steam was a shitty multiplayer idle game sure, but it has to be the shittiest idle game in the world then and Gabe even worse your multiplayer idle game is full of Nazis and extremely toxic behavior none of you give any shit about moderating....

4
DdCno1 beehaw.org DdCno1@beehaw.org
Joined: 2023-06-09
#18 · Quote Reply

Just checked - I got over two hundred trading cards. On one hand, that's a pita to sell individually, on the other hand that's probably a free game in the next sale... But I can do it over time and sell them bit by bit, no hurry...

I haven't checked in a while, but IIRC, there are scripts that can quickly sell your cards without you having to do it manually.

4
thingsiplay lemmy.ml thingsiplay@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2026-01-09
#19 · Quote Reply

Steam isn't a game.

1
frank sopuli.xyz frank@sopuli.xyz
Joined: 2023-06-05
#20 · Quote Reply

I haven't checked in a while, but IIRC, there are scripts that can quickly sell your cards without you having to do it manually.

That'd be cool if so!

1
Hazzard lemmy.zip Hazzard@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-06-28
#21 · Quote Reply

Intriguing.... I'll say, clearly most people don't use the platform that way. But to those who do engage with Steam that much, folks like CS2 case addicts, I can certainly see it. Stuff like cosmetically building out a profile, making sure you have an impressive inventory, the freebies they always give out during sales and events.... yeah. It's reminiscent of endgame MMO behaviour, when you've beaten all the content and just run around looking for rare stuff to show off to your guild.

13
PatheticGroundThing beehaw.org PatheticGroundThing@beehaw.org
Joined: 2023-06-03
#22 · Quote Reply

There's a bevy of "idle" games that are all about that. One if the most popular is literally called Numbers Go Up Idle

That's pretty much the whole point of the incremental genre.

3
wyldrstallyns lemmy.dbzer0.com wyldrstallyns@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2026-05-16
#23 · Quote Reply

Hunh. So, my library of unplayed games is not unlike my health/magic/stamina/et al potion stock after completing a game.

12
Sina beehaw.org Sina@beehaw.org
Joined: 2023-07-02
#24 · Quote Reply

No it isn't. It is not a game. A game is a form of art, Steam exists to make Gabe money it is not a work of art and has no artistic relationship with its players and the fact that Gabe doesn't understand that as CEO of a gaming company is fucking embarassing. I am tired of this lazy conflation of attaching superficial, lazy carrots on sticks to things and calling it "gamification" it is such an...

Not all games are a work of art actually. Especially Asian grinder MMOs are not, such as Silkroad online.

There are many that treat Steam's achievement system kind of like a game, so maybe it can be considered a pseudo game, just barely.

2
Quetzalcutlass lemmy.world Quetzalcutlass@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-02
#25 · Quote Reply

“You level up your account. You get things for playing games.“ Trading cards, profile page decorations, and the like are all tools for self-expression. "There's all of these elements that let you express who you are as a person as well as then MMO-ing the entire experience and leveling up," he says. "Then you have things that you can give to other people, and awards, and all of that." So… like…...

A feature like this only needs to attract a tiny percentage of rich whales to be worth it.

8
jumping redditor [they/them] sh.itjust.works jumping_redditor@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-07-30
#26 · Quote Reply

Intriguing.... I'll say, clearly most people don't use the platform that way. But to those who do engage with Steam that much, folks like CS2 case addicts, I can certainly see it. Stuff like cosmetically building out a profile, making sure you have an impressive inventory, the freebies they always give out during sales and events.... yeah. It's reminiscent of endgame MMO behaviour, when you've ...

even look at tf2 addicts that don't spend money but instead trade the free stuff the game gives you

2
BCsven lemmy.ca BCsven@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-17
#27 · Quote Reply

“You level up your account. You get things for playing games.“ Trading cards, profile page decorations, and the like are all tools for self-expression. "There's all of these elements that let you express who you are as a person as well as then MMO-ing the entire experience and leveling up," he says. "Then you have things that you can give to other people, and awards, and all of that." So… like…...

Its the game I like to play, but also a bit of a fun challenge to unlock the various badges for a game and compare your rank globally in steam.

4
BJW lemmus.org Epp@lemmus.org
Joined: 2026-02-12
#28 · Quote Reply

That'd be cool if so!

This is the one I use:
https://steaminventoryhelper.com/

2
creamfresh lemmy.world creamfresh@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-07-06
#29 · Quote Reply

At least out of all the yacht money on the planet, his goes to science yachts as well. In no way is he altruistic or he'd not be a billionaire, but he's farther from the evil than the rest of the public billionaires.

So a billionaire can just build a school or something and they're out of the woods? idk

1
tempest lemmy.ca tempest@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-30
#30 · Quote Reply

So a billionaire can just build a school or something and they're out of the woods? idk

Not by today's standards no.

1
Post Reply
Back to top