RetroFed Forums
Your home away from modern life.
I would like to write an opera but where do I start?
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
Posted:   Subject: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote

7   Original
Guy Dudeman
lemmy.world

GuyDudeman@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-05
#2 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Maybe ask /c/operafans

6
Cursed_Fig
lemmy.world
Cursed_Fig@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-04-11
#3 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Just rerelease Lakme, no one will notice

2
Guy Dudeman
lemmy.world

GuyDudeman@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-05
#4 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Maybe ask /c/operafans

Damn. That didn’t work.

3
Shimitar
downonthestreet.eu

Shimitar@downonthestreet.eu
Joined: 2025-01-28
#5 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

The plot....

2
littleomid
feddit.org
littleomid@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-01-12
#6 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Do you know how to write music?

8
ReallyZen
lemmy.ml

reallyzen@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2023-07-09
#7 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

I guess you'd better start with building an appropriate theatre ; don't worry, just follow "Pratica di fabricar scene e macchine ne‘ teatri" and you'll get set up in no time, with gods descending from above, devils surging from the bowels of the earth and other high seas tempests (with monsters) - all the normal things you need in any decent opera. Have fun!

5
Bipauler
sh.itjust.works
Bipauler@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-06-04
#8 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

A pencil and a notepad :p

6
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#9 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Do you know how to write music?

No not really, I have rudimentary knowledge of notes. Could AI help me here? If I hum or sing the tune (The dramatic storyline is partially finished),could an AI engine turn it into a Partitur for each instrument?

-4
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#10 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

The plot....

That is partially finished, I have also selected the voices. In my head I can already hear a lot of the piece, and occasionally I hum partitures from it in the shower.

2
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#11 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Just rerelease Lakme, no one will notice

Well, you would, for starters! No this will be an original piece, I can’t talk about the actual story line - this is HOT baby.

1
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#12 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Maybe ask /c/operafans

I already did- it literally rained insults. I tell you, these heretics won’t be getting any free tickets for premiere night, the luddites.

1
Shimitar
downonthestreet.eu

Shimitar@downonthestreet.eu
Joined: 2025-01-28
#13 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

That is partially finished, I have also selected the voices. In my head I can already hear a lot of the piece, and occasionally I hum partitures from it in the shower.

The shower test proves you are ready. Just record it (audio only) on the shower and post it on social media...

4
aim4harmony
lemmy.world
aim4harmony@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-03-27
#14 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Go have a roller coaster ride and "write" it out with your screams. As you calm down, there will be no opera left in your mind. 🤭

2
chloroken
lemmy.ml
chloroken@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2024-11-15
#15 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

No not really, I have rudimentary knowledge of notes. Could AI help me here? If I hum or sing the tune (The dramatic storyline is partially finished),could an AI engine turn it into a Partitur for each instrument?

Amazing. Wants to write an opera, has no idea how written music works (but has knowledge of notes, thank god), and then wants to use AI to bridge the gap instead of learning a fucking thing.

10
chloroken
lemmy.ml
chloroken@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2024-11-15
#16 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

I already did- it literally rained insults. I tell you, these heretics won’t be getting any free tickets for premiere night, the luddites.

Are they Luddites because they said using AI to write your opera is a laughable premise? Because they're right, you know.

5
aim4harmony
lemmy.world
aim4harmony@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-03-27
#17 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

A pencil and a notepad :p

Aaaa Oooo Iiiii Uuuuu Eeeehhh.. 🤭

2
MurrayL
lemmy.world
MurrayL@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#18 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

No not really, I have rudimentary knowledge of notes. Could AI help me here? If I hum or sing the tune (The dramatic storyline is partially finished),could an AI engine turn it into a Partitur for each instrument?

Weren’t you in another thread claiming to be a musicologist with 45+ years experience? And yet you can’t read or write music without AI?

4
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#19 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Weren’t you in another thread claiming to be a musicologist with 45+ years experience? And yet you can’t read or write music without AI?

Yes, it’s very frustrating.

-2
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#20 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Are they Luddites because they said using AI to write your opera is a laughable premise? Because they're right, you know.

Why should it be laughable? It is not as if I’m suggesting that it should be sung by robots… although… although… this gets me thinking! perhaps I better shut up , the world is full of thieves.

1
yopyop
sh.itjust.works
yopyop@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-12
#21 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Start with immersing yourself into operas. Old pieces, contemporary pieces... this could be a good start.

4
littleomid
feddit.org
littleomid@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-01-12
#22 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

No not really, I have rudimentary knowledge of notes. Could AI help me here? If I hum or sing the tune (The dramatic storyline is partially finished),could an AI engine turn it into a Partitur for each instrument?

Ragebait

1
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#23 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Ragebait

How could anyone get enraged by this cultural question ? People these days…

-1
littleomid
feddit.org
littleomid@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-01-12
#24 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

How could anyone get enraged by this cultural question ? People these days…

“Can I drive a formula one car?”

“Idk, can you drive a car?”

“No but can’t I ask AI to drive for me?”

Literally the definition of ragebait. As a formally trained musician I can only tell you to just drop it when that’s your attitude. Good luck.

1
klankin
piefed.ca
klankin@piefed.ca
Joined: 2026-01-12
#25 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Yes, it’s very frustrating.

I can only imagine.

3
BlackSnack
lemmy.zip
BlackSnack@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-08-29
#26 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

That’s so dope! Will you upload a video of the finished product to Lemmy ?

1
HobbitFoot
thelemmy.club
HobbitFoot@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-16
#27 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

How could anyone get enraged by this cultural question ? People these days…

Most instances of Lemmy have a very low opinion of AI. You aren't going to find AI recommendations here.

Also, regarding music, a lot of music theory is used in the writing of opera and musicals. AI could write music for you, but you wouldn't be able to critique the output to make a decent opera. People educated in music would be able to tell what is missing/wrong and people without this education would still likely be and to tell that doesn't hit.

3
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#28 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

That’s so dope! Will you upload a video of the finished product to Lemmy ?

Alas, that’s not part of the business plan at this stage, but I will offer lower pricing for students. Would that work for you?

1
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#29 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Most instances of Lemmy have a very low opinion of AI. You aren't going to find AI recommendations here. Also, regarding music, a lot of music theory is used in the writing of opera and musicals. AI could write music for you, but you wouldn't be able to critique the output to make a decent opera. People educated in music would be able to tell what is missing/wrong and people without this educat...

I don’t want to dwell too much on the AI bit (although AI is making great strides), because it quickly gets people “on the fence”. I mean, the creative part part is mine, and the melody too; tatata dum-di-dum taraaaaah! But I don’t want to give too much away.

-2
susieq0044
sh.itjust.works
susieq0044@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2026-09-13
#30 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

I can only imagine.

I doubt that!

-1
klankin
piefed.ca
klankin@piefed.ca
Joined: 2026-01-12
#31 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

The shower test proves you are ready. Just record it (audio only) on the shower and post it on social media...

They passed the shower test??

How are they not signed to a label already

1
JoeTheSane
lemmy.world
JoeTheSane@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#32 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Sorry, I only know when they end

1
Cursed_Fig
lemmy.world
Cursed_Fig@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-04-11
#33 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Well, you would, for starters! No this will be an original piece, I can’t talk about the actual story line - this is HOT baby.

lmao

0
Cursed_Fig
lemmy.world
Cursed_Fig@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-04-11
#34 Posted:   Subject: Re: I would like to write an opera but where do I start? Quote Reply

Well, you would, for starters! No this will be an original piece, I can’t talk about the actual story line - this is HOT baby.

I suppose the real first step would be to watch a few with the script in your hand and then just steal everything you like. That's how art works, anyway.

If I understand correctly, it's common for the composer and the script writer to be different people, so... maybe team up?

2
Post Reply Page 1