RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Does Might Make Right?
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
futurk feddit.org futurk@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-07-06
Quote

3   Original
t3rmit3 beehaw.org t3rmit3@beehaw.org
Joined: 2023-06-16
#2 · (edited) Quote Reply

No, which is why authority is a problem. Authority is literally "might-enforced hierarchy".

Unfortunately, this author is also attached to authority, under the guise of a hierarchy of morality. "Moral authority", by the author's claim, is the counterpart to might-based authority.

This falls apart when you run into different forms of morality (especially ones where there's not some near-universal social agreement about it, like rights of minors, rights of healthcare, rights of marriage, etc). Moral Authority is just a social and linguistic construct to justify non-consensual imposition of rules.

"Right" is ultimately best judged by Consent: If someone is consenting to something for themself, it likely is Right. If someone is not consenting to something for themself, it likely is Wrong.

Authority in any form is just a justification (through force, or through claimed Moral Superiority upon whose basis force will be applied) to override Consent in order to impose one's will on another.

5
Post Reply
Back to top