RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
RTFC!
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
Hofmaimaier feddit.org NichEherVielleicht@feddit.org
Joined: 2025-01-22
(edited) Quote

Henry's plan for the W40k series.

284   Original
Hideakikarate sh.itjust.works Hideakikarate@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-07-18
#2 · Quote Reply

After the fallout with him and Netflix, I'm glad to see that he's able to flex his nerd knowledge again.

106
[object Object] lemmy.ca panda_abyss@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2025-07-20
#3 · Quote Reply

This guy is great

12
Randomgal lemmy.ca Randomgal@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2024-01-17
#4 · Quote Reply

How is this not literally in the contract when working with q specific IP?

57
Boomer Humor Doomergod lemmy.world Semi_Hemi_Demigod@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-03-15
#5 · Quote Reply

How is this not literally in the contract when working with q specific IP?

“We want to broaden the appeal to bring more people into the universe so when we make more content tangentially related to the IP more people watch them.”

It’s step 2 of the enshittification steps for media companies. Step 3 is blaming the fans when they say they don’t like the new stuff because it’s totally different from what they loved.

57
RightHandOfIkaros lemmy.world RightHandOfIkaros@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-15
#6 · (edited) Quote Reply

How is this not literally in the contract when working with q specific IP?

Seeking a mythical "wider, modern audience" rather than appealing to the core fans.

It is an excellent strategy to alienate everyone and tank an IPs value, to be used as a tax write-off.

24
CyberEgg discuss.tchncs.de CyberEgg@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-22
#7 · Quote Reply

How so? The original lore is a mess and several details have changed over years while novelists have contradicted each other multiple times.

28
TachyonTele piefed.social TachyonTele@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-03
Banned
#8 · Quote Reply

How so? The original lore is a mess and several details have changed over years while novelists have contradicted each other multiple times.

Never underestimate a writers ability to fuck shit up. One easy example is the Halo tv show.

18
CobblerScholar lemmy.world CobblerScholar@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-15
#9 · Quote Reply

How so? The original lore is a mess and several details have changed over years while novelists have contradicted each other multiple times.

The sincere effort I think is what's most important. Even if the show contradicts some of the existing lore one can still make a good faith argument as to why something is added or left out due to other reasons in-universe and out

32
insufferableninja sh.itjust.works imsufferableninja@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2024-11-26
#10 · Quote Reply

After the fallout with him and Netflix, I'm glad to see that he's able to flex his nerd knowledge again.

What netflix fallout?

12
Pennomi lemmy.world pennomi@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-17
#11 · Quote Reply

What netflix fallout?
[deleted]
74
Endymion_Mallorn kbin.melroy.org Endymion_Mallorn@kbin.melroy.org
Joined: 2024-11-17
#12 · Quote Reply

Which edition of the Codex? 3e is the farthest I'll go.

4
Hideakikarate sh.itjust.works Hideakikarate@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-07-18
#13 · Quote Reply

[deleted]

While he was a walking encyclopedia of Witcher lore, wanting to give fans the best representation/adaption of the source material that could be made.

60
CyberEgg discuss.tchncs.de CyberEgg@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-22
#14 · Quote Reply

The sincere effort I think is what's most important. Even if the show contradicts some of the existing lore one can still make a good faith argument as to why something is added or left out due to other reasons in-universe and out

Yeah sure. If they wrote "Henry Cavill's rule ensures a lore-faithful adaptation" - fine, that would be great. "100% Lore Accurate" is an impossible standard that just ensures many an immature nerd will load their keyboard with religious intent.

22
deadbeef79000 lemmy.nz deadbeef79000@lemmy.nz
Joined: 2023-06-17
#15 · Quote Reply

This guy is great

He's one of the greatest actors of his generation IMHO.

And apparently a strong personal set of ethics from at least what I've read about him in the media.

9
ShinkanTrain lemmy.ml ShinkanTrain@lemmy.ml
Joined: 2024-06-13
#16 · Quote Reply

Least annoying Warhammer fan:

19
ParlimentOfDoom piefed.zip ParlimentOfDoom@piefed.zip
Joined: 2025-09-26
#17 · Quote Reply

Never underestimate a writers ability to fuck shit up. One easy example is the Halo tv show.

Are you saying that Master Cheeks wouldn't have had sex with a POW?

7
🇰 🌀 🇱 🇦 🇳 🇦 🇰 🇮 pawb.social Kolanaki@pawb.social
Joined: 2024-10-06
#18 · (edited) Quote Reply

Yeah sure. If they wrote "Henry Cavill's rule ensures a lore-faithful adaptation" - fine, that would be great. "100% Lore Accurate" is an impossible standard that just ensures many an immature nerd will load their keyboard with religious intent.

Maybe the show will be just as convoluted and contradictory so it's 100% accurate. 🤷‍♂️

11
ChicoSuave lemmy.world ChicoSuave@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-12
#19 · (edited) Quote Reply

How is this not literally in the contract when working with q specific IP?

The people who pay to use the IP put up so much money that it has to be crowd sourced among a few rich people/orgs. The money doesn't care about the property, only the opportunity to leverage this into more money. They are paying for an opportunity.

With this opportunity they make a product that uses the nouns of the source material with varying levels of concern for the output. Not all money is the same and some care about the deliverable more than others. Compare Sony comic book movies to Disney and you can see what having a big comics nerd like Feige can do to keep it true to the material while keeping the content new.

Netflix didn't care about what fans consider truth. They wanted content for their catalogue. Most makers of media don't care about what they make as long as it's popular and any lawsuits don't drain the gains.

8
Flying_Penguin lemmy.zip Flying_Penguin@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-02-11
#20 · Quote Reply

Maybe the show will be just as convoluted and contradictory so it's 100% accurate. 🤷‍♂️

I would be okay with that. Really lets the viewer get a sense of the effects of Chaos. /s

5
dellish lemmy.world dellish@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-11
#21 · Quote Reply

[deleted]

Not only couldn't they keep to cannon, they butchered it horribly. The Witcher is set in a world of rich lore and history, almost none of which is explored or explained in that shitful show. The first season is basically the first book put in a blender and strained through a sieve, and the second season, as far as I can tell, is a load of crap. I gave up after that.

36
Lileath lemmy.blahaj.zone Lileath@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2023-06-28
#22 · Quote Reply

He's one of the greatest actors of his generation IMHO. And apparently a strong personal set of ethics from at least what I've read about him in the media.

Except for his views on consent

-4
CobblerScholar lemmy.world CobblerScholar@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-15
#23 · Quote Reply

Yeah sure. If they wrote "Henry Cavill's rule ensures a lore-faithful adaptation" - fine, that would be great. "100% Lore Accurate" is an impossible standard that just ensures many an immature nerd will load their keyboard with religious intent.

Just imagining a Space Marine Chaplain slamming a Crozius onto a keyboard screaming about heretics lol

5
Art3mis lemmy.world ThunderQueen@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-09-15
#24 · Quote Reply

Except for his views on consent
[deleted]
19
Lumisal lemmy.world Lumisal@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-03-16
#25 · Quote Reply

Which edition of the Codex? 3e is the farthest I'll go.

If you're asking that question you probably have already read at least 1 I assume

4
ramble81 lemmy.zip ramble81@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2025-06-08
#26 · Quote Reply

While he was a walking encyclopedia of Witcher lore, wanting to give fans the best representation/adaption of the source material that could be made.

And they were Netflix.

21
ryathal sh.itjust.works ryathal@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-16
#27 · Quote Reply

Never underestimate a writers ability to fuck shit up. One easy example is the Halo tv show.

The writers were forced into using Halo for that show. They wanted to do their own thing and the producers made them use the license.

7
Fluke feddit.uk Fluke@feddit.uk
Joined: 2025-07-01
#28 · Quote Reply

He should be playing Ciaphas Cain in some "Blackadder goes Imperial Guardsman" flashback recounting of his life. Even cherry picking just the ripest stories would get a few potentially great movies by my estimation.

10
ryathal sh.itjust.works ryathal@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-06-16
#29 · Quote Reply

How is this not literally in the contract when working with q specific IP?

I'm surprised it's not a thing for this. Games Workshop is generally pretty protective of their IP. They license it out like crazy, but generally in pretty restricted bits unless you prove some level of respect.

12
Rainbowblite lemmy.ca Rainbowblite@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2025-02-11
#30 · Quote Reply

[deleted]

He was perfect for the role too. If they stuck to the story, it would have been an amazing series.

11
insufferableninja sh.itjust.works imsufferableninja@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2024-11-26
#31 · Quote Reply

Not only couldn't they keep to cannon, they butchered it horribly. The Witcher is set in a world of rich lore and history, almost none of which is explored or explained in that shitful show. The first season is basically the first book put in a blender and strained through a sieve, and the second season, as far as I can tell, is a load of crap. I gave up after that.

I haven't read any of the books and barely played the games, so I don't know much about the world. I did enjoy the first season, less so the second, and didn't make it far into season 3

5
Tanoh lemmy.world Tanoh@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-24
#32 · Quote Reply

[deleted]

Didn't the writers just ignore the source material and thought they could write better? Which made them effectively write fan fiction. And even by those standards, bad fan fiction.

23
GalacticGrapefruit lemmy.world GalacticGrapefruit@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-01-30
#33 · Quote Reply

What netflix fallout?

He's a passionate nerd with a deep love for his people, and he fought the corpos on the canon he knew better than they did.

15
RememberTheApollo_ lemmy.world RememberTheApollo_@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-26
#34 · Quote Reply

I hope Cavill’s a decent dude IRL, he seems like a cool dude when it comes to nerding out on his roles.

19
Bakkoda lemmy.world Bakkoda@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-02-28
#35 · Quote Reply

Didn't the writers just ignore the source material and thought they could write better? Which made them effectively write fan fiction. And even by those standards, bad fan fiction.

1:30 seconds into episode 1 season 3 Geralt is openly attacking humans. Now I'm sure there's bullshit that explains it but that's as far as I made it because fuck Netflix.

14
Endymion_Mallorn kbin.melroy.org Endymion_Mallorn@kbin.melroy.org
Joined: 2024-11-17
#36 · Quote Reply

If you're asking that question you probably have already read at least 1 I assume

Yes, Codex: Craftworld Eldar.

4
aGlassDarkly piefed.zip aGlassDarkly@piefed.zip
Joined: 2025-10-09
#37 · (edited) Quote Reply

I haven't read any of the books and barely played the games, so I don't know much about the world. I did enjoy the first season, less so the second, and didn't make it far into season 3

Season 4 is really fun to watch either as a drinking game or as a target for shit-talking with whoever is on the couch with you. I don’t remember any of the plot, which is probably for the best.

5
paultimate14 lemmy.world paultimate14@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-18
#38 · Quote Reply

How so? The original lore is a mess and several details have changed over years while novelists have contradicted each other multiple times.

Shhh don't ruin it: everyone in the comments is too busy swooning

3
cactusupyourbutt lemmy.world cactusupyourbutt@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-09
#39 · Quote Reply

1:30 seconds into episode 1 season 3 Geralt is openly attacking humans. Now I'm sure there's bullshit that explains it but that's as far as I made it because fuck Netflix.

there is a reason why he was called the butcher of blaviken

he didnt sell meat

6
Bakkoda lemmy.world Bakkoda@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-02-28
#40 · Quote Reply

there is a reason why he was called the butcher of blaviken he didnt sell meat

Provocation. This was not that.

4
CookieOfFortune lemmy.world CookieOfFortune@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#41 · Quote Reply

How so? The original lore is a mess and several details have changed over years while novelists have contradicted each other multiple times.

I just hope they get the Imperial Truth vs Imperial Creed part right.

3
Yeather lemmy.ca yeather@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2023-06-07
#42 · (edited) Quote Reply

“We want to broaden the appeal to bring more people into the universe so when we make more content tangentially related to the IP more people watch them.” It’s step 2 of the enshittification steps for media companies. Step 3 is blaming the fans when they say they don’t like the new stuff because it’s totally different from what they loved.

Games Workshop is really good at doing 2 and 3, they destroyed an entire setting and product line doing it.

6
Lileath lemmy.blahaj.zone Lileath@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Joined: 2023-06-28
#43 · Quote Reply

[deleted]

https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-44819116

2
Rakonat lemmy.world Rakonat@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#44 · Quote Reply

I hope Cavill’s a decent dude IRL, he seems like a cool dude when it comes to nerding out on his roles.

He almost didn't get to be superman because he was raiding in WoW when his agent called.

12
deadbeef79000 lemmy.nz deadbeef79000@lemmy.nz
Joined: 2023-06-17
#45 · Quote Reply

https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-44819116

God damn it.

2
cactusupyourbutt lemmy.world cactusupyourbutt@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-09
#46 · Quote Reply

Provocation. This was not that.

oh scuse me, I didnt realize youre talking about season 3. yeah idk, I didnt watch past s2

2
Karjalan lemmy.world Karjalan@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-05-09
#47 · Quote Reply

He almost didn't get to be superman because he was raiding in WoW when his agent called.

Most relatable celebrity moment

2
Bakkoda lemmy.world Bakkoda@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-02-28
#48 · Quote Reply

oh scuse me, I didnt realize youre talking about season 3. yeah idk, I didnt watch past s2

I should have been smart like you. Every few months i forget, fire up S3 and then ragequit.

1
Tar_Alcaran sh.itjust.works Tar_alcaran@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-10-06
#49 · Quote Reply

Games Workshop is really good at doing 2 and 3, they destroyed an entire setting and product line doing it.

Excuse you.

They destroyed several different product lines.

2
Post Reply
Back to top