RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
It be like that
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
cm0002 suppo.fi cm0002@suppo.fi
Joined: 2025-11-10
Quote

212   Original
Warl0k3 lemmy.world Warl0k3@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-11
#2 · (edited) Quote Reply

The universe is eminently describable with language - thats the whole point of mathematics.

4
WhiteHotaru feddit.org WhiteHotaru@feddit.org
Joined: 2024-06-23
#3 · Quote Reply

Wittgenstein: die Grenzen meiner Sprache sind die Grenzen meiner Welt.

3
AnarchoEngineer lemmy.dbzer0.com AnarchoEngineer@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2025-06-04
#4 · (edited) Quote Reply

While qualia are not directly communicable, even they are labelable. All that can be differentiated can be labeled, if only by reference to its differences from other things (or other relations to other things). And if something cannot be differentiated, then there’s no need to have a word/label for it.

We don’t have separate words for red-green and yellow because we perceive them the same way. If we ran into aliens that didn’t, then it’d be relevant to create a word for it, and I just did by calling it “red-green”

When we need a word for something new we create one. And sure sometimes it takes science a while to refine definitions, and yeah, in natural languages words have really blurry definitions which obscures communication, but that’s not a property of the universe or a fundamental flaw in all languages, just our limited experiences and non-formal languages.

Point is: all that is relevant to be communicated via language could be communicated via some language.

6
kozy138 slrpnk.net kozy138@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-11-19
#5 · Quote Reply

The universe is eminently describable with language - thats the whole point of mathematics.

Okay. Describe a flower using mathematics. It better entail every detail of the flower and all of its virtues.

6
kibiz0r midwest.social kibiz0r@midwest.social
Joined: 2023-07-14
#6 · (edited) Quote Reply

Yuuup. And then we turn the words into numbers and run a few bajillion matrix multiplications on em to produce some sentences that bear a similarity to the sentences we make, and go “omg! It can navigate the nature of the universe the same way a human does!”

Also, MFs in the comments relitigating privacy of consciousness and Mary the color scientist lmao

1
cholesterol lemmy.world cholesterol@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-21
#7 · Quote Reply

>Using words to undermine using words

2
Viceversa lemmy.world Viceversa@lemmy.world
Joined: 2025-12-29
#8 · Quote Reply

The universe is eminently describable with language - thats the whole point of mathematics.

It's not: see Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorems.

2
Warl0k3 lemmy.world Warl0k3@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-11
#9 · (edited) Quote Reply

Okay. Describe a flower using mathematics. It better entail every detail of the flower and all of its virtues.

Oh you seem fun. The vast body of mathematics describes flowers, from growth patterns to genetic structure to the effect it has on human neurology when observing the colorful patterns made by them. However I am curious; please explain what a virtue is!

5
ChaoticNeutralCzech feddit.org ChaoticNeutralCzech@feddit.org
Joined: 2024-06-23
#10 · Quote Reply

And then there's people thinking if we feed computers enough language, they will be able to solve everything

2
Warl0k3 lemmy.world Warl0k3@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-11
#11 · Quote Reply

It's not: see Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorems.

I am at a loss as to what they have to do with this, do you mean to say that the universe is not exhaustively describable?

2
Etterra discuss.online Etterra@discuss.online
Joined: 2024-12-10
#12 · Quote Reply

No, language is trying to sort the water.

1
starman2112 sh.itjust.works starman2112@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2023-08-10
#13 · Quote Reply

And then there's people thinking if we feed computers enough language, they will be able to solve everything

If we can simply train these machines on all the writings of straight white first-world men, then they'll be free of all bias and produce only objective facts!

1
arnitbier sh.itjust.works arnitbier@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-13
#14 · (edited) Quote Reply

Oh you seem fun. The vast body of mathematics describes flowers, from growth patterns to genetic structure to the effect it has on human neurology when observing the colorful patterns made by them. However I am curious; please explain what a virtue is!
[removed by moderator]
1
Warl0k3 lemmy.world Warl0k3@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-11
#15 · (edited) Quote Reply

[removed by moderator]

Do you mean the person who tried to use a cliche'd gotcha as a result of their misunderstanding of what mathematics is? Or me who was unimpressed by the aforementioned cliche'd anti-intellectualism in their comment? Because there is no nuance here that I have missed - they pulled out the deeply tired idea that mathematics, which is a descriptive language, has not yet comprehensively described all of what constitutes a "flower" and thus cannot conceivably do that - which is a patently absurd requirement that belies an utter lack of understanding of the fundemental purpose of mathematics or the function of language in general.

1
arnitbier sh.itjust.works arnitbier@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-13
#16 · (edited) Quote Reply

Do you mean the person who tried to use a cliche'd gotcha as a result of their misunderstanding of what mathematics is? Or me who was unimpressed by the aforementioned cliche'd anti-intellectualism in their comment? Because there is no nuance here that I have missed - they pulled out the deeply tired idea that mathematics, which is a descriptive language, has not yet comprehensively described a...
[removed by moderator]
1
Warl0k3 lemmy.world Warl0k3@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-11
#17 · (edited) Quote Reply

[removed by moderator]

"Oh I see you actually responded to what I was saying - I'm not here for a discussion or to be wrong, I'm just here to be smugly superior, so I'm just going to ignore that" - you, apparently?

If you want to discuss the ideas here feel free, I do enjoy doing that, but jeeze I hope you're drunk posting because this is deeply embarassing behavior...

edit:

Man, taking the insults and victim blaming to the DMs, you are way too into this.

Edit 2:

I am looking forward to the apology for your behavior.

Edit 3:

Gonna be real there hamdogger, I don't even know what this is supposed to mean.

Edit 4:

Mmm...hmm.

Edit 5:

Yeah...

Edit 6:

Appended without comment.

Edit 7:

Nah, man, this was fun but it's getting boring. Pease puddins' to you.

1
arnitbier sh.itjust.works arnitbier@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-13
#18 · (edited) Quote Reply

"Oh I see you actually responded to what I was saying - I'm not here for a discussion or to be wrong, I'm just here to be smugly superior, so I'm just going to ignore that" - you, apparently? If you want to discuss the ideas here feel free, I do enjoy doing that, but jeeze I hope you're drunk posting because this is deeply embarassing behavior... edit: Man, taking the insults and victim blaming...
[removed by moderator]
1
Warl0k3 lemmy.world Warl0k3@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-10-11
#19 · Quote Reply

[removed by moderator]

Jokes on you, my mom's trailer doesn't even have a basement.

1
kozy138 slrpnk.net kozy138@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2024-11-19
#20 · Quote Reply

Oh you seem fun. The vast body of mathematics describes flowers, from growth patterns to genetic structure to the effect it has on human neurology when observing the colorful patterns made by them. However I am curious; please explain what a virtue is!

I sort of meant it more as a joke.

But what I was telling to portray, is that there are an infinite number of 'parameters', if you will, that a flower contains. And sure, mathematics can describe each of those parameters. But we will never be able to quantify it completely, as there are an infinite number of ways to relate flowers existence, and to any and every other 'thing' in the universe. Even if the mathematics is still there as the underlying building block.

Just like I can language to 'invent' or 'discover' a new sentence in order to describe anything and everything. But I won't be able to describe it completely, as there are an infinite number of ways to describe something.

1
Post Reply
Back to top