RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Map Lie
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
pEg startrek.website pEg@startrek.website
Joined: 2024-10-26
Quote

425   Original
bdonvr thelemmy.club bdonvr@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-14
#2 · Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny.

It's bigger than Australia

109
ryannathans aussie.zone ryannathans@aussie.zone
Joined: 2023-09-20
#3 · Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny. It's bigger than Australia

Does that mean Australia is not the biggest island

16
bdonvr thelemmy.club bdonvr@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-14
#4 · Quote Reply

Does that mean Australia is not the biggest island

Are continents islands?

28
damnthefilibuster lemmy.world damnthefilibuster@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-05
#5 · Quote Reply

Friendly reminder that Europe is not a continent.

7
damnthefilibuster lemmy.world damnthefilibuster@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-05
#6 · Quote Reply

Are continents islands?

The Australia thing is something we were taught in high school.

6
bdonvr thelemmy.club bdonvr@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-14
#7 · (edited) Quote Reply

The Australia thing is something we were taught in high school.

I think I remember being told Greenland was the largest island, while Australia was a continent

Something to do with tectonic plates

13
ryannathans aussie.zone ryannathans@aussie.zone
Joined: 2023-09-20
#8 · Quote Reply

Are continents islands?

There is no agreed upon definition or set of continents globally

It might as well be a made up word

26
MinnesotaGoddam lemmy.world HeyThisIsntTheYMCA@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-27
#9 · Quote Reply

There is no agreed upon definition or set of continents globally It might as well be a made up word

the just be making up words now

12
Town lemmy.zip Town@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-03-03
#10 · Quote Reply

the just be making up words now

What will they think of next?

7
MinnesotaGoddam lemmy.world HeyThisIsntTheYMCA@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-27
#11 · Quote Reply

What will they think of next?

ook

4
lugal lemmy.dbzer0.com lugal@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-06-26
#12 · Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny. It's bigger than Australia

Hence "most other continents"

3
lugal lemmy.dbzer0.com lugal@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-06-26
#13 · Quote Reply

I think I remember being told Greenland was the largest island, while Australia was a continent Something to do with tectonic plates

Continents is a human made construct that's later rationalized with tectonic plates and other criteria. Basically, people around the Mediterranean Sea divided the Mediterranean Coast into 3 parts and later extended this concept.

12
lugal lemmy.dbzer0.com lugal@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-06-26
#14 · Quote Reply

Friendly reminder that Europe is not a continent.

If Europe isn't a continent then neither is India!

6
bdonvr thelemmy.club bdonvr@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-14
#15 · Quote Reply

Hence "most other continents"

Yeah it's smaller but not tiny

1
Fleur_ aussie.zone Fleur_@aussie.zone
Joined: 2025-04-23
#16 · Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny. It's bigger than Australia

Fake map north should be pointing away from Antarctica dumbass. Read a book.

46
JayDee lemmy.world JayDee@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-11-08
#17 · Quote Reply

Continents is a human made construct that's later rationalized with tectonic plates and other criteria. Basically, people around the Mediterranean Sea divided the Mediterranean Coast into 3 parts and later extended this concept.

Yeah, but so is an island. It's all human constructs. we see patterns and make up sounds for them.

3
lugal lemmy.dbzer0.com lugal@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-06-26
#18 · Quote Reply

Yeah, but so is an island. It's all human constructs. we see patterns and make up sounds for them.

Yes of cause

1
deadbeef79000 lemmy.nz deadbeef79000@lemmy.nz
Joined: 2023-06-17
#19 · (edited) Quote Reply

If Europe isn't a continent then neither is India!

It gets called The Indian subcontinent for exactly that reason but not Europe because of colonialism.

5
nightlily leminal.space nightlily@leminal.space
Joined: 2024-08-08
#20 · Quote Reply

I think I remember being told Greenland was the largest island, while Australia was a continent Something to do with tectonic plates

If you go by the geological definition, Australia is a continent, as is Zealandia. That’s right, New Zealand has equal geological footing with the entirety of Eurasia.

4
MrVilliam sh.itjust.works MrVilliam@sh.itjust.works
Joined: 2025-06-29
#21 · Quote Reply

the just be making up words now

All words are made up

8
MinnesotaGoddam lemmy.world HeyThisIsntTheYMCA@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-27
#22 · Quote Reply

All words are made up

no i'm doesn't

3
Zorque lemmy.world Zorque@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-08-13
#23 · Quote Reply

If you go by the geological definition, Australia is a continent, as is Zealandia. That’s right, New Zealand has equal geological footing with the entirety of Eurasia.

Probably why they keep getting left off maps, jealousy.

5
dohpaz42 lemmy.world dohpaz42@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#24 · Quote Reply

Are continents islands?

Not all continents, no. Islands are bodies of land surrounded by water on all sides, no? Wouldn’t Antarctica and Australia then qualify by that definition?

1
bdonvr thelemmy.club bdonvr@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-14
#25 · Quote Reply

Not all continents, no. Islands are bodies of land surrounded by water on all sides, no? Wouldn’t Antarctica and Australia then qualify by that definition?

I mean every landmass is surrounded on all sides by water though

6
dohpaz42 lemmy.world dohpaz42@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-01
#26 · Quote Reply

I mean every landmass is surrounded on all sides by water though

But most of the land that are considered continents are connected to one or kore other land, and thus couldn’t be defined as an island.

Though, after reading a few other comments, it seems the definition of what makes a continent a continent is apparently subject to debate.

~This is why we can’t have nice things.~

4
damnthefilibuster lemmy.world damnthefilibuster@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-05
#27 · Quote Reply

If Europe isn't a continent then neither is India!

How dare you! Oh, wait, I agree!

2
grue lemmy.world grue@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-13
#28 · (edited) Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny. It's bigger than Australia

That outline is like the entire continental shelf, or all the area where the glaciers are directly over rock (as opposed to having ocean in between), or something like that.

But if the ice weren't there, not all of it would actually be above sea level:

Might actually be smaller than Australia if the ice were gone, give or take things like sea level rise and isostatic rebound.

20
skisnow lemmy.ca skisnow@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2025-03-22
#29 · Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny. It's bigger than Australia

Nice. What did you use for that one?

https://niy.ai/worldmap lets you reproject Mercator to put any landmass you want in the middle by clicking on it, but it doesn't have that overlay thing.

2
skisnow lemmy.ca skisnow@lemmy.ca
Joined: 2025-03-22
#30 · Quote Reply

Fun fact, Mercator would in principle be even more distorted than it is, but almost every map that uses it crops at least the top and bottom 5 degrees to hide it. Mercator's original cropped to 66°S - 80°N, which shifts Europe towards the middle.

8
lordbritishbusiness lemmy.world lordbritishbusiness@lemmy.world
Joined: 2024-12-18
#31 · Quote Reply

Does that mean Australia is not the biggest island

Apparently Greenland is considered the largest island. The difference between a continent and island is a little arbitrary.

7
bdonvr thelemmy.club bdonvr@thelemmy.club
Joined: 2023-06-14
#32 · Quote Reply

Nice. What did you use for that one? https://niy.ai/worldmap lets you reproject Mercator to put any landmass you want in the middle by clicking on it, but it doesn't have that overlay thing.

https://thetruesize.com/

7
marcos lemmy.world marcos@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-16
#33 · Quote Reply

That outline is like the entire continental shelf, or all the area where the glaciers are directly over rock (as opposed to having ocean in between), or something like that. But if the ice weren't there, not all of it would actually be above sea level: Might actually be smaller than Australia if the ice were gone, give or take things like sea level rise and isostatic rebound.

TIL that Antarctica is an archipelago.

8
MufinMcFlufin lemmy.world MufinMcFlufin@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-09
#34 · Quote Reply

Friendly reminder that Europe is not a continent.

Are we going with Eurasia or an Afro-Eurasia distinction? I feel like if someone were to insist on Afro-Eurasia then they also have to accept The Americas, or I guess it would just be a simple "America" which would get confusing since that's a pretty common verbal shorthand for USA. Under that sort of definition I think if you still insist on North and South America as regions then you'd have to also accept North and South Afro-Eurasia.

It'd also be pretty funny to try to argue that since North America was connected to Asia within the human timeline it should also be added. Imagine trying to refer to the continents: AfroAmeriEurasia, Australia, and Antarctic, with an optional Oceania thrown in the mix.

For clarity, I usually just go with North/South America, Australia, Antarctica, Africa, and Eurasia as the continental landmasses

2
pHr34kY lemmy.world pHr34kY@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-02
#35 · (edited) Quote Reply

Are continents islands?

By definition, a continent and an island are mutually exclusive. Nothing can be both.

Australia isn't a continent either. It's in the continent of Oceania, which includes New Zealand.

Antarctica is a continent in its own right. It's not a country and not a nation.

2
ExcessShiv lemmy.dbzer0.com ExcessShiv@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Joined: 2024-04-23
#36 · Quote Reply

There is no agreed upon definition or set of continents globally It might as well be a made up word

All words are made up words...

1
thebestaquaman lemmy.world thebestaquaman@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-18
#37 · Quote Reply

Are continents islands?

I may be mistaken here, but I think the concept of a "continental shelf" is pretty well defined geologically. That is: Outside a land mass, the ocean floor extends a certain distance before dropping off to the deep ocean floor. An island would be a piece of land that sticks out of the sea from this continental shelf, while the "continent" includes the entire shelf, and all the land masses that stick out of the ocean on that shelf.

Of course, this seems to break down a bit for e.g. the Europe/Asia divide (and probably a lot more), but the concept of "continents" vs. "islands" can make sense geologically, although the "continents" are then different from the geopolitical borders ones we usually talk about.

2
thebestaquaman lemmy.world thebestaquaman@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-18
#38 · Quote Reply

Fun fact, Mercator would in principle be even more distorted than it is, but almost every map that uses it crops at least the top and bottom 5 degrees to hide it. Mercator's original cropped to 66°S - 80°N, which shifts Europe towards the middle.

Another fun-fact: The Mercator projection was, at its inception, the first map that could be used for long-distance sea navigation over the mediterranean and Atlantic in the sense that axes are scaled such that courses plotted on the map actually match the compass course you need to follow to get somewhere. This also happens to be the reason it became popular, and the reason it was made, rather than the commonly quoted reason of "making Europe big at the expense of things closer to the equator".

5
NeatNit discuss.tchncs.de NeatNit@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2024-01-05
#39 · Quote Reply

Are we going with Eurasia or an Afro-Eurasia distinction? I feel like if someone were to insist on Afro-Eurasia then they also have to accept The Americas, or I guess it would just be a simple "America" which would get confusing since that's a pretty common verbal shorthand for USA. Under that sort of definition I think if you still insist on North and South America as regions then you'd have t...

Excellent Map Men video about this: https://youtu.be/hrsxRJdwfM0

2
katkit lemmy.world katkit@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-07-13
#40 · Quote Reply

Another fun-fact: The Mercator projection was, at its inception, the first map that could be used for long-distance sea navigation over the mediterranean and Atlantic in the sense that axes are scaled such that courses plotted on the map actually match the compass course you need to follow to get somewhere. This also happens to be the reason it became popular, and the reason it was made, rather...

And Mercator means merchant in Latin. I thought that was because of the projection's purpose, but turns out that the inventer's name was actually Mercator, which was a latinisation of his Flemish birthname Kremer (meaning grocer or merchant).

2
thebestaquaman lemmy.world thebestaquaman@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-18
#41 · Quote Reply

And Mercator means merchant in Latin. I thought that was because of the projection's purpose, but turns out that the inventer's name was actually Mercator, which was a latinisation of his Flemish birthname Kremer (meaning grocer or merchant).

Now that is a fun-fact! I knew the guy was called Mercator, but didn't know about the Latin origin, and can definitely see the origin of the name spreading as a misconception.

3
captainlezbian lemmy.world captainlezbian@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-29
#42 · Quote Reply

That outline is like the entire continental shelf, or all the area where the glaciers are directly over rock (as opposed to having ocean in between), or something like that. But if the ice weren't there, not all of it would actually be above sea level: Might actually be smaller than Australia if the ice were gone, give or take things like sea level rise and isostatic rebound.

If the ice weren't there a lot of the other continents would also be below sea level

5
prettybunnys piefed.social prettybunnys@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-06-10
#43 · Quote Reply

TIL that Antarctica is an archipelago.

You’re an archipelago

3
captainlezbian lemmy.world captainlezbian@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-29
#44 · Quote Reply

I may be mistaken here, but I think the concept of a "continental shelf" is pretty well defined geologically. That is: Outside a land mass, the ocean floor extends a certain distance before dropping off to the deep ocean floor. An island would be a piece of land that sticks out of the sea from this continental shelf, while the "continent" includes the entire shelf, and all the land masses that ...

That definition however does some weird things like saying that Tokyo and parts of Siberia are in North America, but Panama and Los Angeles aren't.

A continent is mostly just a social convention for a bigass geographic and geological structure that is above sea level and largely geologically and culturally separated. North and South America are connected by a land bridge, but that's really recent in evolutionary time and it's a real pain in the ass to cross. Europe and Asia are historically separated by the Ural mountains, but it's hard to look at them in modern day and say "these are two distinct landmasses" especially if you're saying India isn't, but historically getting from Europe to what's worth going to in Asia has involved crossing the Mediterranean much like getting to Africa or sailing around Africa in the early modern period. Australia is a giant landmass with not much else around as is Antarctica.

1
captainlezbian lemmy.world captainlezbian@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-29
#45 · Quote Reply

If Europe isn't a continent then neither is India!

If India is a continent then so is Somalia! And Arabia, but for some reason Arabia being it's own continent feels kinda right considering it really feels like neither Eurasia nor Africa, just a large mass between them

1
captainlezbian lemmy.world captainlezbian@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-29
#46 · Quote Reply

Are we going with Eurasia or an Afro-Eurasia distinction? I feel like if someone were to insist on Afro-Eurasia then they also have to accept The Americas, or I guess it would just be a simple "America" which would get confusing since that's a pretty common verbal shorthand for USA. Under that sort of definition I think if you still insist on North and South America as regions then you'd have t...

So long as we include Hokkaido in North America that's good by me

2
ptu sopuli.xyz ptu@sopuli.xyz
Joined: 2025-06-04
#47 · Quote Reply

I mean it's greatly exaggerated on Mercator but it's definitely not tiny. It's bigger than Australia

Also bigger than Texas

1
potoooooooo 🥔 lemmy.world ivanafterall@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-20
#48 · Quote Reply

Also bigger than Texas

It's just like they say: "everything's bigger than Texas!"

3
Post Reply
Back to top