RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
Stubsack: weekly thread for sneers not worth an entire post, week ending 26th April 2026
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
BlueMonday1984 awful.systems BlueMonday1984@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-02-02
Quote

Want to wade into the sandy surf of the abyss? Have a sneer percolating in your system but not enough time/energy to make a whole post about it? Go forth and be mid.

Welcome to the Stubsack, your first port of call for learning fresh Awful you’ll near-instantly regret.

Any awful.systems sub may be subsneered in this subthread, techtakes or no.

If your sneer seems higher quality than you thought, feel free to cut’n’paste it into its own post — there’s no quota for posting and the bar really isn’t that high.

The post Xitter web has spawned so many “esoteric” right wing freaks, but there’s no appropriate sneer-space for them. I’m talking redscare-ish, reality challenged “culture critics” who write about everything but understand nothing. I’m talking about reply-guys who make the same 6 tweets about the same 3 subjects. They’re inescapable at this point, yet I don’t see them mocked (as much as they should be)

Like, there was one dude a while back who insisted that women couldn’t be surgeons because they didn’t believe in the moon or in stars? I think each and every one of these guys is uniquely fucked up and if I can’t escape them, I would love to sneer at them.

(Credit and/or blame to David Gerard for starting this.)

16   Original
CinnasVerses awful.systems CinnasVerses@awful.systems
Joined: 2025-08-23
#2 · Quote Reply

Ex-CEO, ex-CFO of bankrupt AI company iLearningEngines charged with fraud - Reuters, 17 April 2026

Prosecutors said iLearning marketed itself as an artificial intelligence-driven digital education ​company with an "out-of-the-box AI platform," and claimed to earn revenue mainly by selling ​licenses for its educational and training platforms to customers, including healthcare companies and schools.

According to the ‌indictment, ⁠the defendants used forged sham contracts to make it seem that iLearning's customers were real, and used "round trip" transfers of investor and lender funds -- meaning they sent money to purported customers, who then returned it to iLearning -- to manufacture revenue.

At least ​90% of iLearning's $421 million ​of reported revenue ⁠in 2023 was fabricated, the indictment said.

I think they called this wash trading in cryptoland.

16
BlueMonday1984 awful.systems BlueMonday1984@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-02-02
#3 · Quote Reply

shot:

chaser:

12
aninjury2all awful.systems aninjury2all@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-05-08
#4 · Quote Reply

Somebody check if Sam’s got a pied-a-terre in NYC that’s gonna be taxed under this new proposal

6
gerikson awful.systems gerikson@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-01
#5 · (edited) Quote Reply

Somebody check if Sam’s got a pied-a-terre in NYC that’s gonna be taxed under this new proposal

Why? So it can be firebombed?

(don't fire-bomb residences people)

also it's hilarious that a 5% local tax surcharge on a place you don't even live in is considered Stalinism

7
gerikson awful.systems gerikson@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-01
#6 · Quote Reply

Look I know Doctorow fails the gen-AI purity test but I think he's making sense here

https://pluralistic.net/2026/04/16/pascals-wager/

5
Evinceo awful.systems Evinceo@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#7 · Quote Reply

Somebody check if Sam’s got a pied-a-terre in NYC that’s gonna be taxed under this new proposal

This has been getting posted repeatedly on a reddit sub I follow and it's funny that we're still finding Harris fans who somehow didn't catch on for all these years that the dude is just straight up racist and hates Muslims on an individual basis. The fact that he was probably the most commonly mentioned podcaster on the slate star codex sub is a sign!

I'll steal my general remark from one of the threads on DTG:

Sam, if you're allowed to call the mayor an Islamist because his wife liked some posts on social media, can we call you a racist for having a notorious racist on your podcast to yammer about the woke menace?

10
Evinceo awful.systems Evinceo@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#8 · Quote Reply

Look I know Doctorow fails the gen-AI purity test but I think he's making sense here https://pluralistic.net/2026/04/16/pascals-wager/

It's not just that he fails a purity test it's that he basically only cares about his pet issues like right to repair and hating copyright and positions himself as a social activist while twisting real social issues to fit into his framework of 'copyright bad, hackers fix this.'

14
jaschop awful.systems jaschop@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-27
#9 · (edited) Quote Reply

Look I know Doctorow fails the gen-AI purity test but I think he's making sense here https://pluralistic.net/2026/04/16/pascals-wager/

Too narrow of a scope to be useful I think.

When he talks about LLCs, the real thing he's referring to has to be capitalism. The "unaligned AI is already here, it's corporations" trope has been around for a while, and I don't think it convinced a lot of people to become socialists.

I think you can't usefully tackle just the capitalism of the tech industry, if you don't understand the wider system around it. I mean the VC that sloshes around in tech to raise up one bullshitteer after another comes from somewhere. Real estate, mining, fossil fuels, etc.

9
gerikson awful.systems gerikson@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-01
#10 · (edited) Quote Reply

Habryka @ LW takes a break from reinventing Western civilization from first Rat principles to advocate a RETVRN to incandescent lighting:

Eventually, in most of the western world outside of the US, incandescent lightbulbs were literally banned to promote energy saving policies.

This was the greatest uglification in history. Within two decades, much of the world that was previously filled with beautiful natural-feeling light started feeling alien, slightly off, and uncomfortable, and societal stigma around energy-saving policies prevented people from really doing anything about it.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/dWib7qinqymfxevE4/if-a-room-feels-off-the-lighting-is-probably-too-spiky-or

11
YourNetworkIsHaunted awful.systems YourNetworkIsHaunted@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-03-22
#11 · Quote Reply

shot: chaser:

I can't imagine the Mouse being happy about this cameo.

9
o7___o7 awful.systems o7___o7@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-10-08
#12 · (edited) Quote Reply

shot: chaser:

For the uninformed (like myself), the odd fox out is a character from Zootopia (pic related), which is a Disney movie.

Bold move to steal from The Mouse in broad daylight, isn't it?

6
blakestacey awful.systems blakestacey@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
#13 · Quote Reply

New random positivity thread:

https://awful.systems/post/8018168

12
CinnasVerses awful.systems CinnasVerses@awful.systems
Joined: 2025-08-23
#14 · Quote Reply

Habryka @ LW takes a break from reinventing Western civilization from first Rat principles to advocate a RETVRN to incandescent lighting: Eventually, in most of the western world outside of the US, incandescent lightbulbs were literally banned to promote energy saving policies. This was the greatest uglification in history. Within two decades, much of the world that was previously filled with b...

Who TF was using LED lights for indoor lighting in the 1990s? Compact flourescents were the lightbulb replacement in the oughties.

And how TF do you write that post without using the phrase "sensory sensitivity" and citing some women who know they have autism? Once you know you are more sensitive to your environment than allistics, you can start to experiment with interventions.

12
YourNetworkIsHaunted awful.systems YourNetworkIsHaunted@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-03-22
#15 · Quote Reply

Habryka @ LW takes a break from reinventing Western civilization from first Rat principles to advocate a RETVRN to incandescent lighting: Eventually, in most of the western world outside of the US, incandescent lightbulbs were literally banned to promote energy saving policies. This was the greatest uglification in history. Within two decades, much of the world that was previously filled with b...

Dramatic fascistic "RETVRN" language and focus on aesthetics aside, my wife and I actually dug into some of this lighting quality stuff a while ago and while our very good friend here does a poor job explaining it there is a definite difference in normal LEDs vs incandescent or natural light. The LED spectra is fascinating - big spikes at a couple wavelengths and nothing in between. In my experience with switching to the fancier high-CRI LEDs the difference is pretty minimal. Feels like a possible case where you don't notice it, but your brain does. For my wife it seems to have helped reduce the incidence and severity of her crippling migraines, which is obviously more impactful. I don't think I'd say it beautified the space or brought us back to the halcyon days of our glorious past, but that's been huge for us all the same. The plural of anecdote is not cliche, but there's not nothing here.

10
Evinceo awful.systems Evinceo@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#16 · Quote Reply

Too narrow of a scope to be useful I think. When he talks about LLCs, the real thing he's referring to has to be capitalism. The "unaligned AI is already here, it's corporations" trope has been around for a while, and I don't think it convinced a lot of people to become socialists. I think you can't usefully tackle just the capitalism of the tech industry, if you don't understand the wider syst...

When he talks about LLCs, the real thing he’s referring to has to be capitalism. The “unaligned AI is already here, it’s corporations” trope has been around for a while, and I don’t think it convinced a lot of people to become socialists.

Nah, this is the threat as he describes it:

Every moment that we remain stuck in the enshitternet is a moment of existential risk. At the click of a mouse, Trump could order John Deere to switch off all the tractors in your country

He doesn't need tanks to steal Greenland. He can just shut off Denmark's access to American platforms like Office365, iOS and Android and brick the whole damned country. It would be another Strait of Hormuz, but instead of oil and fertilizer, he'd control the flow of Lego, Ozempic and deliciously strong black licorice

He's not saying that "corporations are a parasitic species we created that will devour our precious planet and ability to survive and turn it into shareholder value for our corpses to enjoy" no sir he's saying we need to switch to open source replacements for Office 360 and get Right To Repair for our tractors.

4
jaschop awful.systems jaschop@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-27
#17 · Quote Reply

When he talks about LLCs, the real thing he’s referring to has to be capitalism. The “unaligned AI is already here, it’s corporations” trope has been around for a while, and I don’t think it convinced a lot of people to become socialists. Nah, this is the threat as he describes it: Every moment that we remain stuck in the enshitternet is a moment of existential risk. At the click of a mouse, Tr...

Yeah, but he's been saying this for a while, and I don't think this is a new way of saying it that is particularly useful.

4
Amoeba_Girl awful.systems Amoeba_Girl@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-10-16
#18 · Quote Reply

Habryka @ LW takes a break from reinventing Western civilization from first Rat principles to advocate a RETVRN to incandescent lighting: Eventually, in most of the western world outside of the US, incandescent lightbulbs were literally banned to promote energy saving policies. This was the greatest uglification in history. Within two decades, much of the world that was previously filled with b...

jesus fucking christ this is insufferable, these guys have been masking off for so long now that they're scraping the bottom of the barrel to find new things to do fascist signalling about

7
Soyweiser awful.systems Soyweiser@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-09-07
#19 · Quote Reply

Reminder to update your github settings if you don't want AI to train on it, before 24 april.

9
Soyweiser awful.systems Soyweiser@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-09-07
#20 · Quote Reply

Habryka @ LW takes a break from reinventing Western civilization from first Rat principles to advocate a RETVRN to incandescent lighting: Eventually, in most of the western world outside of the US, incandescent lightbulbs were literally banned to promote energy saving policies. This was the greatest uglification in history. Within two decades, much of the world that was previously filled with b...
This was the greatest uglification in history.

Seems like a market opportunity for some special lights/glass that recreates the natural feeling light they want. (I have some lower light leds in older style lamps and I'm having, for me, nice and cosy lighting. Only issue seems to be me getting older and my eyes getting worse with age.

6
BurgersMcSlopshot awful.systems BurgersMcSlopshot@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-01-15
#21 · Quote Reply

shot: chaser:

looks up, shrugs Everybody involved here kind of sucks, best of luck to all of them. looks back down

6
Evinceo awful.systems Evinceo@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#22 · Quote Reply

Yeah, but he's been saying this for a while, and I don't think this is a new way of saying it that is particularly useful.

Agreed

4
blakestacey awful.systems blakestacey@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
#23 · Quote Reply

looks up, shrugs Everybody involved here kind of sucks, best of luck to all of them. looks back down

When we're all too tired for "let them fight".

5
fullsquare awful.systems fullsquare@awful.systems
Joined: 2025-03-31
#24 · (edited) Quote Reply

I can't imagine the Mouse being happy about this cameo.

damn i wish i had confidence of a mediocre techbro. twitter thread suggests that there's four copyright infringements just in these two images

e: still can't get fingers right, lol

6
sc_griffith awful.systems sc_griffith@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-08-13
#25 · Quote Reply

guys

goodtrip blockchain enabled agentic cannabis vape

21
blakestacey awful.systems blakestacey@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-06-27
#26 · Quote Reply

guys

This is a serious blow to coolness, from which not even drugs will easily recover.

17
YourNetworkIsHaunted awful.systems YourNetworkIsHaunted@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-03-22
#27 · Quote Reply

Too narrow of a scope to be useful I think. When he talks about LLCs, the real thing he's referring to has to be capitalism. The "unaligned AI is already here, it's corporations" trope has been around for a while, and I don't think it convinced a lot of people to become socialists. I think you can't usefully tackle just the capitalism of the tech industry, if you don't understand the wider syst...

Yeah. I mean, I'm going to assume that he's not specifically referring to LLCs and that, say General Partnerships and Sole Proprietorship aren't actually better, mostly because they absolutely share the same problems. But that's a whole lot of digital ink spilled about how important it is to create "digital public goods" - and one assumes public goods more generally, given our ongoing inability to subsist on digital food - without any real thought put to how such systems should be organized, controlled, protected, etc. Like, if he stopped trying to wave "digital innovation" around like a magic wand he'd basically have to be a communist or anarchist of some flavor. But he's still sufficiently in the Silicon Valley Milieu where lefty politics are too cringe to admit, so he's stuc having identified some real problems and having no realistic starting point for solving them

6
BurgersMcSlopshot awful.systems BurgersMcSlopshot@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-01-15
#28 · Quote Reply

guys

Agentic Ripz is my new jam band.

10
zogwarg awful.systems zogwarg@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#29 · Quote Reply

guys

John Oliver dismissingly saying cool meme

10
swlabr awful.systems swlabr@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#30 · Quote Reply

guys

Wake me up when there’s an agentic butt plug

10
YourNetworkIsHaunted awful.systems YourNetworkIsHaunted@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-03-22
#31 · Quote Reply

guys

I'm sorry, I think I need to believe that this is taking the piss in order to be able to function. It can't be real (It''s definitely real).

Oh God I read their FAQ and it looks like the whole concept is to gamify smoking weed because if there's one problem with weed it's that it's not addictive enough on its own. I mean the actual concept is to try and smash enough hip tech buzzwords together to extract some amount of the dwindling venture capital continuing to slosh around the valley, but if it actually happens the thing it's going to do is take all the addictionware tactics that app developers have developed and bring them to bear on promoting drug use.

17
YourNetworkIsHaunted awful.systems YourNetworkIsHaunted@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-03-22
#32 · Quote Reply

For the uninformed (like myself), the odd fox out is a character from Zootopia (pic related), which is a Disney movie. Bold move to steal from The Mouse in broad daylight, isn't it?

You can see also his rabbit counterpart from Zootopia in a princess dress in the background of the first picture!

4
JFranek awful.systems JFranek@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-10-09
#33 · Quote Reply

Looks like Mythos didn't catch this one:

Anthropic secretly installs spyware when you install Claude Desktop

Whoopsie!

14
JFranek awful.systems JFranek@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-10-09
#34 · Quote Reply

Wake me up when there’s an agentic butt plug

You made me look and now you all have to know there's a library for butt plugs (written in Rust) that has LLM generated code in it:

https://github.com/buttplugio/buttplug#inclusion-of-llm-generated-code

12
swlabr awful.systems swlabr@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-04
#35 · Quote Reply

You made me look and now you all have to know there's a library for butt plugs (written in Rust) that has LLM generated code in it: https://github.com/buttplugio/buttplug#inclusion-of-llm-generated-code

I have mixed feelings about speaking things into existence

9
Architeuthis awful.systems Architeuthis@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-02
#36 · (edited) Quote Reply

Look I know Doctorow fails the gen-AI purity test but I think he's making sense here https://pluralistic.net/2026/04/16/pascals-wager/

It's not so much he fails the purity test than it is he thinks all gen-ai works like whisper on a laptop and open source LLMs grow on trees.

edit: and also that big company engineers are encouraged to be discreet in using them, like what?

8
Architeuthis awful.systems Architeuthis@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-02
#37 · (edited) Quote Reply

You can see also his rabbit counterpart from Zootopia in a princess dress in the background of the first picture!

I assume that's more because they used AI to lift zootopia's art style wholesale and so that's just how rabbits are now.

4
Soyweiser awful.systems Soyweiser@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-09-07
#38 · Quote Reply

Looks like Mythos didn't catch this one: Anthropic secretly installs spyware when you install Claude Desktop Whoopsie!

Well it does have the secret "Any attempt to arrest a senior officer of OCP results in shutdown" derective.

6
Soyweiser awful.systems Soyweiser@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-09-07
#39 · Quote Reply

You made me look and now you all have to know there's a library for butt plugs (written in Rust) that has LLM generated code in it: https://github.com/buttplugio/buttplug#inclusion-of-llm-generated-code

Considering the amount of weird hentai on the internet that cannot end well.

4
istewart awful.systems istewart@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-08-26
#40 · Quote Reply

guys

If it's "agentic," doesn't that imply it smokes weed for you

14
lagrangeinterpolator awful.systems lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems
Joined: 2025-05-16
#41 · Quote Reply

Looks like Mythos didn't catch this one: Anthropic secretly installs spyware when you install Claude Desktop Whoopsie!

It's fine, spyware is only a risk when it's bad people's spyware. It's totally fine when it's Anthropic™-approved spyware!

As for Mythos catching things, maybe they should have used Mythos on their very own Claude Code considering that it has hilariously obvious security exploits, such as this one which inserts an arbitrary string into a shell command. Actually, never mind I don't see anything wrong here, maybe we should burn another $20k in electricity running Mythos on it again to find out.

10
V0ldek awful.systems V0ldek@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-01-16
#42 · Quote Reply

You made me look and now you all have to know there's a library for butt plugs (written in Rust) that has LLM generated code in it: https://github.com/buttplugio/buttplug#inclusion-of-llm-generated-code

This is how I learn that buttplug.io has fallen

I hurt myself today...
to see if I still feel...

5
gerikson awful.systems gerikson@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-01
#43 · Quote Reply

Habryka doesn't have time to write all the crazy shit he's mulling on, so he offers a summary.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/MqgwHJ93pJpaeHXs6/posts-i-don-t-have-time-to-write

Do you enjoy living in a society that takes fire safety seriously? Sucks to be you, I guess:

  1. Fire codes are the root of all evil

How about we just make all the mosquito nets flammable. That's effective altruism!

Also Switzerland is a libertarian paradise apparently.

10
lagrangeinterpolator awful.systems lagrangeinterpolator@awful.systems
Joined: 2025-05-16
#44 · (edited) Quote Reply

Habryka doesn't have time to write all the crazy shit he's mulling on, so he offers a summary. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/MqgwHJ93pJpaeHXs6/posts-i-don-t-have-time-to-write Do you enjoy living in a society that takes fire safety seriously? Sucks to be you, I guess: Fire codes are the root of all evil How about we just make all the mosquito nets flammable. That's effective altruism! Also Sw...

The fire code thing really is an excellent example of LessWrong Brain. Fire truck drivers insist on needlessly large trucks (no citation) which makes roads 30% wider than they would otherwise be (no citation) which has "probably" "non-trivially" contributed to larger cars (no citation) leading to enough additional road fatalities to cancel out the lives saved by stricter fire codes (no citation).

The LessWrong Brain argument starts with a deliberately contrarian conclusion and proves it with a Rube Goldberg chain of logical syllogisms. Of course, citations are strictly optional, and they are free to misinterpret them as they see fit. The only real standard of each claim is "looks good to me", but you are supposed to be impressed that they managed to string a dozen of them together to reveal some shocking, deep truth of the world that nobody else knows about. The AI 2027 nonsense is an infamous example of this.

He uses the word "fermi" which is cult jargon based on Fermi estimation, a.k.a. guessing shit with back-of-the-envelope calculations. Not exactly what you want if you want to convince people to reform fire codes, especially if you have zero citations for anything.

I guess people just aren't rational enough, and the only reason the fire codes are so irrational is because people are emotional about fire codes. Firefighters are apparently revered as heroes, when it is the LWers who should be the heroes. After all, firefighters merely save people from fires, while LWers buy multimillion dollar mansions to talk about saving quadrillions of hypothetical people from hypothetical basilisks!

15
Amoeba_Girl awful.systems Amoeba_Girl@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-10-16
#45 · Quote Reply

Habryka doesn't have time to write all the crazy shit he's mulling on, so he offers a summary. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/MqgwHJ93pJpaeHXs6/posts-i-don-t-have-time-to-write Do you enjoy living in a society that takes fire safety seriously? Sucks to be you, I guess: Fire codes are the root of all evil How about we just make all the mosquito nets flammable. That's effective altruism! Also Sw...

Unfortunately there are a few things that make courts pretty tricky to implement in practice for things like the rationality, AI safety and EA communities. Badly implemented courts also can just make things worse by creating a clear target for attack and pressure. Seems very tricky, but probably we should have more courts (or maybe not, I would need to write the post to figure it out).

yesss yesss lesswrong people's tribunals and struggle sessions let's gooooooooo

15
gerikson awful.systems gerikson@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-01
#46 · Quote Reply

Unfortunately there are a few things that make courts pretty tricky to implement in practice for things like the rationality, AI safety and EA communities. Badly implemented courts also can just make things worse by creating a clear target for attack and pressure. Seems very tricky, but probably we should have more courts (or maybe not, I would need to write the post to figure it out). yesss ye...

in b4 "Committee for AI Safety" seizes control and executes people who are too smart with a guillotine.

11
antifuchs awful.systems antifuchs@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-22
#47 · Quote Reply

Is there a more generalized form of “weird hill to die on but at least you’re dead”? Because a new-to-me way for too-rich people to end their gullible lives has emerged https://www.technologyreview.com/2026/03/30/1134780/r3-bio-brainless-human-clones-full-body-replacement-john-schloendorn-aging-longevity/

8
BlueMonday1984 awful.systems BlueMonday1984@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-02-02
#48 · Quote Reply

Two tech-related links for today, both relating to fascism.

First, tante has a new blogpost about AI being overtly fascist in nature, which he's also posted to LinkedIn, seemingly for kicks. (Found on red site, too)

Second, the Nazi laptop company has sent a second pre-release laptop to DHH, showing they have not changed at all since they went full fash six months ago:

14
nfultz awful.systems nfultz@awful.systems
Joined: 2023-07-19
#49 · Quote Reply

https://russwilcoxdata.substack.com/p/and-the-alignment-problem-what-chinas

In June 2025, Zhao Tingyang gave a talk at Tsinghua’s Fangtang Forum. The edited transcript ran in The Paper on July 4 under the title “人工智能的伦理与思维之限” (The Ethical and Thinking Limits of AI). Near the end, Zhao wrote this:

“What requires more reflection is that attempting to ‘align’ AI with human nature and values actually contains a risk of human species suicide. Human nature is selfish, greedy, and cruel. Humans are the most dangerous biological species. Almost all religions demand the restraint of human desire; this is no accident. AI aligned with human values may well become a dangerous subject by imitating humans. Originally, AI does not possess the selfish genes of carbon-based life, so AI is actually closer to the legendary ‘human nature is fundamentally good’ kind of existence, whereas human nature is not ‘fundamentally good.’”
The alignment paradigm treats human values as the target AI should conform to. Zhao is arguing the target is the danger. An AI aligned to human values inherits the specific features of human judgment that Zhao says have produced the record of human harm. The paradigm is not incomplete. It is pointed the wrong way.

Zhao’s argument has developed across CASS, The Paper, and Wenhua Zongheng from late 2022 through 2025, from a provocative aside into a sustained critique of the alignment paradigm. In the same period, the English-language alignment and AI ethics literature produced no substantive engagement. No citations. No rebuttal. No naming. Zhao is a member of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Institute of Philosophy, author of the Tianxia framework, and one of the most cited philosophers working in Chinese today.

I need to think on this a little more, wasn't on my radar.

6
aio awful.systems aio@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-02-06
#50 · Quote Reply

The fire code thing really is an excellent example of LessWrong Brain. Fire truck drivers insist on needlessly large trucks (no citation) which makes roads 30% wider than they would otherwise be (no citation) which has "probably" "non-trivially" contributed to larger cars (no citation) leading to enough additional road fatalities to cancel out the lives saved by stricter fire codes (no citation...

rationalism is when i pull five numbers out of my ass and multiply them together

16
YourNetworkIsHaunted awful.systems YourNetworkIsHaunted@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-03-22
#51 · Quote Reply

https://russwilcoxdata.substack.com/p/and-the-alignment-problem-what-chinas In June 2025, Zhao Tingyang gave a talk at Tsinghua’s Fangtang Forum. The edited transcript ran in The Paper on July 4 under the title “人工智能的伦理与思维之限” (The Ethical and Thinking Limits of AI). Near the end, Zhao wrote this: “What requires more reflection is that attempting to ‘align’ AI with human nature and values actual...

To be fair, while I'm not familiar with the discourse in China I know a lot people consider (rightly) "alignment" as a framing to be a red flag for cranks and rats. It's not that surprising that this attitude hasn't been getting much recognition when the marketing departments of ai companies has been more engaged on that subject than serious academics.

11
Post Reply Page 1 of 3   Goto page 1, 2, 3 Last »
Back to top