RetroFed Forums
Your home away from modern life.
Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse.
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
MastKalandar
feddit.online

MastKalandar@feddit.online
Joined: 2026-04-28
Posted:   Subject: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote

I don't know what discord is, but I find that every social media owner/admin and developer can be reached at discord. Another thing is Matrix.

I've got no clue about these two platforms but I believe that they're not a part of the fediverse.

I very much wish that replicas of these were available on fediverse, so that we could interact with them from our Mastodon, lemmy or other Fediverse handles.

-8   Original
schnurrito
discuss.tchncs.de

schnurrito@discuss.tchncs.de
Joined: 2023-06-24
#2 Posted:   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

Matrix is basically federated Discord based on an open standard. But it's a separate thing from the fediverse.

The thing is that Matrix and Discord are really intended for real time chatting, including private and encrypted chatting, in a way ActivityPub isn't (which is more about persistent public conversations). So it makes sense that they are separate things.

12
rumschlumpel
feddit.org
rumschlumpel@feddit.org
Joined: 2024-06-23
#3 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

IDK if that's a good idea, even Mastodon and Lemmy don't really interact that well. It's easier to just make a separate account for each type of platform.

2
MastKalandar
feddit.online

MastKalandar@feddit.online
Joined: 2026-04-28
#4 Posted:   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

IDK if that's a good idea, even Mastodon and Lemmy don't really interact that well. It's easier to just make a separate account for each type of platform.

I've interacted on lemmy from my mastodon account, but l spend more time on Piefed now.

!dumbquestions@crazypeople.online

1
cerement
slrpnk.net

cerement@slrpnk.net
Joined: 2023-06-10
#5 Posted:   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

IRC

the problem isn’t Discord per se but that everyone insists on using a chatroom to replace support channels, wikis, knowledge-bases, FAQs, forums, announcements, mailing lists, etc.

7
rumschlumpel
feddit.org
rumschlumpel@feddit.org
Joined: 2024-06-23
#6 Posted: · edited   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

I've interacted on lemmy from my mastodon account, but l spend more time on Piefed now. !dumbquestions@crazypeople.online

Lemmy vs Piefed doesn't really make a difference, because it's the same type of Reddit-style platform (also called "threadiverse"), while Mastodon is Twitter-style. The interoperability isn't great IMO, because the usage patterns are quite different. e.g. if you reply to a Mastodon post on a threadiverse platform, the OOP on Mastodon won't see any of the replies, and are probably not even aware that there are threadiverse threads about their post. IIRC you need to @ the OOP in each of your replies, which you need to do manually in the threadiverse, which isn't particularly obvious if you never use Mastodon yourself.

2
troed
fedia.io

troed@fedia.io
Joined: 2023-06-12
#7 Posted:   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

I don't think we need to reinvent Matrix "just" to have some parts of it be based on ActivityPub.

5
silverpill
mitra.social

silverpill@mitra.social
Joined: 2021-11-06
#8 Posted:   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

It's being developed: https://github.com/MaddyUnderStars/shoot

2
MastKalandar
feddit.online

MastKalandar@feddit.online
Joined: 2026-04-28
#9 Posted:   Subject: Re: Seriously there needs to be a Discord replica in fediverse. Quote Reply

It's being developed: https://github.com/MaddyUnderStars/shoot

That looks great πŸ˜ƒπŸ˜ƒ

1
Post Reply Page 1