RetroFed Forum
Your home away from modern life.
whats your thought on open relationship?
Post Reply
AuthorMessage
Baggie lemmy.zip Baggie@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2023-12-23
#102 · Quote Reply

But you think its bad?

Not bad as such, just different from what I could personally do. If it works for some people, good for them.

1
smiletolerantly awful.systems smiletolerantly@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-27
#103 · Quote Reply

I am in one (I think... see below). We agreed to open the relationship, IDK, 7 years ago? Something like that. We're both bi/pan, and sexuality- and kinkwise pretty incompatible. Neither of us was remotely willing to give up the relationship because of that though, because romantically and non-sexual-intimacy wise, the relationship is amazing. Oh god I love her so much.

Anyways, we decided to open the relationship with a couple ground rules:

  1. Always communicate. That includes informing the other person before one goes on a date, for example.
  2. Sex only. We aren't poly, and are both not ok with the idea of romantic connections forming... Romantically monogamous, sexually open, I guess.
  3. Protection, duh.

She went on a couple of dates but didn't actually end up sleeping with anyone, I slept with a couple of people. And... things were cool! It worked out for us. If anything, we grew even closer.

The reason I said above that I "think" we're in an open relationship is simply because neither of us has taken advantage of the openness of the relationship in at least 3 years, lmao. And so if I would decide that I'd like to get active again in that regard, that would 100% be preceded with a "hey, are we still open? Are you still comfortable with that, or have your thoughts changed?" conversation.

1
turdburglar piefed.social turdburglar@piefed.social
Joined: 2025-07-03
#104 · Quote Reply

can i share one thing?

i thought we were talking about sharing multiple ‘things’

1
Malica lemmy.zip Malica@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-08-27
#105 · Quote Reply

How its bad?

Relationships that start out open have a higher chance of success, but opening a previously closed one almost always ends in disaster. The thing is, neither of you will know how you'll feel until after it's too late. It's not worth the risk, if you care about your relationship.

1
thethrilloftime69 feddit.online thethrilloftime69@feddit.online
Joined: 2026-02-12
#106 · Quote Reply

actually one thing happened can i share on messge?

Sure

1
TribblesBestFriend startrek.website TribblesBestFriend@startrek.website
Joined: 2025-01-30
#107 · Quote Reply

he kiss her but the she constantly inform me

Also if this kiss wasn’t consensual, it’s called « rape »

1
sunsofold lemmy.zip sunsofold@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-06-09
#108 · Quote Reply

so if both are in different city its not good?

It's not about the location so much as the expectations and praticalities.
An 'open relationship' as a status requires a commitment from both people to maintain commitment to the relationship but allow casual sexual interactions outside of the relationship. That's hard for a lot of, if not the large majority of, people, even when both people are in close proximity. If you take away the commitment element, it's not a romantic relationship, it's just casual or friend sex, which can be fine too, but has different expectations.
A traditional long-distance relationship also requires commitment. Ask anyone who has tried to have an LDR. It requires a HEAVY commitment, and a lot of every day effort to maintain the non-physical intimacy of the relationship over that distance. Are you ready to spend all day writing texts, call each other when you have a few moments at the same time just to hear each other's voices, and spend all evening on the phone talking about the most pointless BS that happened that day just because you love hearing about each other's BS? If you got the chance to go visit, but you were exhausted from working overtime and it would cost everything you got as extra from the overtime and then a bit more, would you drop everything just to go see them for one day?
These commitments, if they are going to withstand the difficulties of life, are usually on the order of 'we will be getting married or entering a solemnified union of some kind but circumstances outside of our control make that impossible for now.'
If either of the people aren't ready to commit to that level of dedication and permanence, the relationship, while possibly previously good, is not likely to be able to withstand the strain of each person's needs and desires being deferred by the practical realities, again and again and again.
You have to ask yourselves, and each other, out loud, whether that level of commitment is there. If it's not, it's far healthier for everyone involved to say 'This isn't something to call a relationship. I won't wait for you, and I don't expect you to wait for me, but I'll be super fucking happy to try again when we're both living in the same place if we're not monogamous with someone else.'

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#109 · Quote Reply

It's not about the location so much as the expectations and praticalities. An 'open relationship' as a status requires a commitment from both people to maintain commitment to the relationship but allow casual sexual interactions outside of the relationship. That's hard for a lot of, if not the large majority of, people, even when both people are in close proximity. If you take away the commitme...

So its good if both want open relationship?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#110 · Quote Reply

Also if this kiss wasn’t consensual, it’s called « rape »

no after that its consensual so its great na?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#111 · Quote Reply

How do you feel about it ?

Good and romantic>

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#112 · Quote Reply

Relationships that start out open have a higher chance of success, but opening a previously closed one almost always ends in disaster. The thing is, neither of you will know how you'll feel until after it's too late. It's not worth the risk, if you care about your relationship.

so according to you open relationship is always better than closed?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#113 · Quote Reply

For me, I prefer when both me and my bf can be flirty with the person. If the person prefers me or my bf, I fear that it could lead to jealousy, so I try to make sure everyone gets their fair share of flirting :3

so can we all 4 together

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#114 · Quote Reply

Ok so to be poly everyone involved has to be good with it, and if you're not comfortable then it's not poly; it's cheating. My wife wasn't comfortable at first so we talked about it and now she is, but it's definitely not for everyone. The mononormative worldview in our society is DEEPLY ingrained. For the people in my polycule it's healthy and good for us, and all four of us have a good relati...

yes now we comforatbale so its good if we all in one place?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#115 · Quote Reply

Ok so to be poly everyone involved has to be good with it, and if you're not comfortable then it's not poly; it's cheating. My wife wasn't comfortable at first so we talked about it and now she is, but it's definitely not for everyone. The mononormative worldview in our society is DEEPLY ingrained. For the people in my polycule it's healthy and good for us, and all four of us have a good relati...

hey can i share thing on here?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#116 · Quote Reply

I'm split on it. I'm involved with someone who is in one, which basically means I am in one. I don't really want to see anyone else, myself. He already had another BF when we met. Sometimes I wish I was the only one so he'd give me more attention cuz we see each other maybe once a week, if he's not busy wifh work or school or his other friends. Which makes it feel like I'm just the one he sees ...

so its good according to you?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#117 · Quote Reply

I am in one (I think... see below). We agreed to open the relationship, IDK, 7 years ago? Something like that. We're both bi/pan, and sexuality- and kinkwise pretty incompatible. Neither of us was remotely willing to give up the relationship because of that though, because romantically and non-sexual-intimacy wise, the relationship is amazing. Oh god I love her so much. Anyways, we decided to o...

so its nice?, can i ask one thing in chatbox

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#118 · Quote Reply

I am in one (I think... see below). We agreed to open the relationship, IDK, 7 years ago? Something like that. We're both bi/pan, and sexuality- and kinkwise pretty incompatible. Neither of us was remotely willing to give up the relationship because of that though, because romantically and non-sexual-intimacy wise, the relationship is amazing. Oh god I love her so much. Anyways, we decided to o...

so its good we both decide to openness?

1
Bizzle lemmy.world bizzle@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-12
#119 · Quote Reply

yes now we comforatbale so its good if we all in one place?

I'd say so

1
Bizzle lemmy.world bizzle@lemmy.world
Joined: 2023-06-12
#120 · Quote Reply

hey can i share thing on here?

Yeah totally

1
Gyrcas piefed.zip Gyrcas@piefed.zip
Joined: 2026-09-24
#121 · Quote Reply

so can we all 4 together

If all 4 consent, yes

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#122 · Quote Reply

If all 4 consent, yes

coz one thing happened, hey are any other platform also?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#123 · Quote Reply

I'd say so

Not getting

1
Gyrcas piefed.zip Gyrcas@piefed.zip
Joined: 2026-09-24
#124 · Quote Reply

coz one thing happened, hey are any other platform also?

Hum, if I am on another platform? If so, yes, I'm on Discord and Matrix, you can dm me your name on one or the other and we will be able to discuss there if you prefer

1
smiletolerantly awful.systems smiletolerantly@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-27
#125 · Quote Reply

so its nice?, can i ask one thing in chatbox

sure

1
Malica lemmy.zip Malica@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-08-27
#126 · Quote Reply

so according to you open relationship is always better than closed?

No, I'm one of those people this will never work with because I have 3 disabilities dealing with emotional regulation. I lose control of my reactions to stuff. Best not to play with fire there :)

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#127 · Quote Reply

Hum, if I am on another platform? If so, yes, I'm on Discord and Matrix, you can dm me your name on one or the other and we will be able to discuss there if you prefer

yes can you tell me you name so i can search on discord

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#128 · Quote Reply

No, I'm one of those people this will never work with because I have 3 disabilities dealing with emotional regulation. I lose control of my reactions to stuff. Best not to play with fire there :)

sad what happened to you?

1
loveablePerson lemmy.world prash2671990@lemmy.world
Joined: 2026-10-02
#129 · Quote Reply

sure

is it ok to kiss and ask partner?

1
sunsofold lemmy.zip sunsofold@lemmy.zip
Joined: 2026-06-09
#130 · Quote Reply

So its good if both want open relationship?

It can technically be made to work, but it will be extremely hard. It's combining two difficult to manage relationship dynamics into one VERY difficult one. Both people wanting an open relationship is only the bare minimum starting point. It takes a LOT more than that to even begin to make it work.

1
smiletolerantly awful.systems smiletolerantly@awful.systems
Joined: 2024-04-27
#131 · Quote Reply

is it ok to kiss and ask partner?

How do you mean?

Kiss someone else, then ask your partner?

Or are you asking how to approach the topic with your partner?

1
Post Reply Page 3 of 3   Goto page « First 1, 2, 3
Back to top